Divergence of Cross Product Relation

3 replies · 5K views · last reply
advphys
Messages
17
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


The problem is given in the following photo:
Typed homework problem with parts (a), (b) and (c): the scalar triple product interchange rule, the vector triple product identity A x (B x C) = (A.C)B - (A.B)C, and the product rule for grad(f.g), followed by two identities to prove.

Actually I did the first proof but I couldn't get the second relation. (Divergence of E cross H).

Homework Equations


They are all given in the photo. (a) (b) and (c).

The Attempt at a Solution


What I tried is to interchange divergence and cross products as it was given in (a). But I couldn't figure out how I am going to get 2 terms at the end. I also tried to apply the relation in (c), but it does not have any cross product, and I think there is no way to use equation in (b). So how can I prove the equation given at the end by using (a) (b) or (c) without decomposing into components or using Einsteins notation.
 
The product rule, as it appears in (c), is a vector equation. Its ith component is ##\partial_i (fg)=(\partial_i f)g+f\partial_ig##. If you use the definition of the cross product to rewrite the cross products in the problem, you will encounter expressions of the form ##\partial_i (fg)##.

Edit: In this problem, you don't even have to use the definition, since (c) also tells you that if f and g are vector-valued functions, you're allowed to use that ##\partial_i (f\cdot g)=(\partial_i f)\cdot g+f\cdot\partial_ig## and ##\partial_i (f\times g)=(\partial_i f)\times g+f\times\partial_i g##.
 
That is right. I didn't think using that for cross product. After that I can use (a) to prove the given relation.

It seems this was a little bit dummy question.

Thank you very much!
 
Looking at the problem again, I see that the final sentence tells you NOT to use the definition of the cross product to rewrite it in terms of components. But you can still use the comment I added when I edited my previous post.