Divergence theorem in four(or more) dimension

6 replies · 7K views · last reply
enricfemi
Messages
195
Reaction score
0
I don't know whether it was proved or can be prove.

I don't know whether it is useful. maybe it can be used in string theory or some other things.

any comment or address will be appreciated.
 
What you want is (the generalized) Stoke's theorem for differential forms.
 
Start with the Gauss-Green theorem. [itex]\Omega \in \Re^d[/itex], [itex]u:\Re^d \rightarrow \Re[/itex], n unit normal to [itex]\Omega[/itex] with components ni:

[tex] \int_\Omega \frac{\partial}{\partial x_i} u dx = \int_{\partial \Omega} u n_i dS[/tex]

Now apply this theorem to each term of [itex]\nabla \cdot F = \sum_i \frac{\partial}{\partial x_i}F_i[/itex] to get the result on Rd.
 
What is "meaning"?

It is a logical consequence of the axioms of maths we have chosen to use.

Isn't that "meaning" enough for you?
 
It might have an interesting interpretation in terms of flows of probability density through a higher dimensional phase space.

For example in 2D phase space where we can visualize it, consider simple harmonic motion of a single mass on a spring:
Two panels: left, a red mass on a zigzag spring hanging from a ceiling, labelled Real Space; right, a blue circular orbit with a green dot on it in a Position versus Velocity plane, labelled Phase Space.


The orbit is a circle whose radius depends on how far the string stretches at the maximum. If you don't know the initial position or velocity exactly, you could consider the state of the system to be a probability distribution occupying some volume in phase space. It might be interesting to ask, how much probability is flowing into or out of a given region of phase space. Using this theorem, you could relate to the divergence of the tangent vector field inside the region of phase space to the flux through the boundary.

Now this is 2D phase space, but if you start adding in more springs and masses connected in various ways, the dimension of the phase space is going to get much bigger since you will need an axis for each position and velocity of each component.

I don't know if people who study dynamical systems actually use this, but its the first reasonable thing that I could think of.
 
Attachments
  • Two-panel diagram: left, a red mass on a zigzag spring hanging from a ceiling labelled Real Space; right, a blue circular orbit in a Phase Space plot with Position on the vertical axis and Velocity on the horizontal axis, with a green dot on the orbit.
    Simple_Harmonic_Motion_Orbit.gif
    38.8 KB · Views: 882
  • Two-panel diagram: left, a mass on a spring hanging from a ceiling labelled Real Space; right, a blue circular orbit in a Phase Space plot with Position on the vertical axis and Velocity on the horizontal axis, with a green dot on the orbit.
    Simple_Harmonic_Motion_Orbit.gif
    38.8 KB · Views: 780
  • Side-by-side diagram: left, a red mass on a spring hanging from a ceiling labelled Real Space; right, a blue circular orbit in a phase space plot with Position on the vertical axis and Velocity on the horizontal axis, with a green dot on the circle.
    Simple_Harmonic_Motion_Orbit.gif
    38.8 KB · Views: 552
  • Side-by-side diagram: left panel 'Real Space' shows a red mass on a zigzag spring hanging from a ceiling, with a green dot on the mass; right panel 'Phase Space' shows a blue circular orbit labelled 'Orbit' with axes 'Position' (vertical) and 'Velocity' (horizontal), and a green dot on the circle.
    Simple_Harmonic_Motion_Orbit.gif
    38.8 KB · Views: 520
  • Two-panel diagram: left panel titled Real Space shows a mass on a spring hanging from a ceiling; right panel titled Phase Space shows a blue circular orbit plotted against Position (vertical axis) and Velocity (horizontal axis), with a green dot on the orbit.
    Simple_Harmonic_Motion_Orbit.gif
    38.8 KB · Views: 544
  • Side-by-side diagram: left panel 'Real Space' shows a red mass on a zigzag spring hanging from a ceiling, with a green dot on the mass; right panel 'Phase Space' shows a blue circular orbit labeled 'Orbit' with axes 'Position' (vertical) and 'Velocity' (horizontal), and a green dot on the circle.
    Simple_Harmonic_Motion_Orbit.gif
    38.8 KB · Views: 497
  • Side-by-side diagram: left, a red mass on a spring hanging from a ceiling labelled Real Space; right, a blue circular orbit in a plane with axes Position (vertical) and Velocity (horizontal), labelled Phase Space, with a green dot on the circle.
    Simple_Harmonic_Motion_Orbit.gif
    38.8 KB · Views: 504
  • Side-by-side diagram: left panel 'Real Space' shows a red mass on a zigzag spring hung from a ceiling, with a green dot on the mass; right panel 'Phase Space' shows a blue circular orbit plotted against Position (vertical axis) and Velocity (horizontal axis), with a green dot on the circle.
    Simple_Harmonic_Motion_Orbit.gif
    38.8 KB · Views: 538
Last edited:
Special thanks to maze!

by the way, i still have a question:
for a vector field, how to define the "probability density"?
i don't think it is divergence,
but it's really exist and important. just like the density of electric field lines exhibit its strength.