Medical Do European Starlings Show Evidence of Recursive Language?

  • Thread starter Thread starter selfAdjoint
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
Recent discussions center on a paper published in Nature that suggests European starlings exhibit evidence of a recursive language module similar to that proposed by Chomsky. This claim has sparked critical evaluations, particularly regarding the methodology and conclusions drawn by the researchers. A notable critique can be found on a language blog that also provides an introduction to cognitive linguistic theory. The conversation touches on animal behavior, with anecdotes about squirrels and their interactions with humans, highlighting how animals can mimic sounds and exhibit complex behaviors. However, the distinction is made between simple imitative behaviors and the true recursive capabilities that would indicate a more advanced language processing system. Critics argue that the evidence presented for starlings does not convincingly demonstrate the existence of such a recursive language ability.
selfAdjoint
Staff Emeritus
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
Messages
6,843
Reaction score
11
Can Starlings "recurse"

There's a paper out in Nature claiming experiments that demonstrate European starlings show evidence of a recursive language module a la Chomsky, and this has prompted several critical evaluations. The best one I have found is at http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/003076.html, which has a link to the paper. As a bonus it has some intro to cognitive linguistic theory.
 
Biology news on Phys.org
selfAdjoint said:
There's a paper out in Nature claiming experiments that demonstrate European starlings show evidence of a recursive language module a la Chomsky, and this has prompted several critical evaluations. The best one I have found is at http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/003076.html, which has a link to the paper. As a bonus it has some intro to cognitive linguistic theory.

We have a small woods near our house that a family of squirrels used to live in when I was younger. They'd run around our housing estate and we'd feed them monkey nuts (shelled peanuts).

I used to whistle to them when I saw one and it'd come over to see if I had any peanuts left; they could burry a bag of them in no time! I must have planted a few hundred peanut bushes around here by now with their help.

One day I was out in the garden and noticed a familiar sound, a bird on a roof nearby was tweeting the same pattern I'd been whistling to the squirrels. I was pretty impressed! :biggrin:

I was perhaps more impressed to see that the squirrels had been 'playing my ass'. I'd been wondering where they could be burrying the nuts that allowed them to get back to me so quickly, and this wondering developed into tying a long piece of string to my backdoor's handle and then to the nuts, which the squirrels would run off with at speed and burry (unless they ran out of string first, twaaaang). It was hard to find the nuts even when I'd just watched the squirrel burry it. But one day the mystery was solved when I discovered they were working me in shifts, as one was about to disappear it would wave it's tail round a bit (it'd also responded to me if I made similar movements) and then take off, only for it's brother or sister to run into the garden from the other side and into the kitchen.

Not particularly high tech neural stuff, but it always makes me smile when I see animals behaving in such human ways.

The squirrels were great, they'd climb along the washing line and up my pants if they thought there was a peanut to be gained from any of it, although their claws were evilly sharp!

I just started looking after hives of bees and it's interesting watching them really, really close up in person. I'm also supervising some ants that seem to be building a house under some wood tiling in our house. During the day, every 30s or so, one comes up through a gap in the tile with a single grain of soil, walks for a bit, puts it down and goes back. I've even seen ants working in two lanes, one going in and the other coming out. Amazing stuff!
 
Last edited:
As you say, these behaviors, which I also enjoy, are low tech, basically imitation or regurgitation of a remembered bit. The link discusses the various kinds of language processors theorists have devised, and the squirrels and mocking bird's behavior can be attained by just tacking a memory store onto a finite state machine. But true parsing of a context-free language requires a system that is recursive, and thus potentially infinite state. This is what the researchers claim for their starlings, and what most language researchers believe they have not succeeded in showing.
 
Thread 'Did they discover another descendant of homo erectus?'
The study provides critical new insights into the African Humid Period, a time between 14,500 and 5,000 years ago when the Sahara desert was a green savanna, rich in water bodies that facilitated human habitation and the spread of pastoralism. Later aridification turned this region into the world's largest desert. Due to the extreme aridity of the region today, DNA preservation is poor, making this pioneering ancient DNA study all the more significant. Genomic analyses reveal that the...
Popular article referring to the BA.2 variant: Popular article: (many words, little data) https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/17/health/ba-2-covid-severity/index.html Preprint article referring to the BA.2 variant: Preprint article: (At 52 pages, too many words!) https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.02.14.480335v1.full.pdf [edited 1hr. after posting: Added preprint Abstract] Cheers, Tom
https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/conditions/body-dysmorphia/ Most people have some mild apprehension about their body, such as one thinks their nose is too big, hair too straight or curvy. At the extreme, cases such as this, are difficult to completely understand. https://www.msn.com/en-ca/health/other/why-would-someone-want-to-amputate-healthy-limbs/ar-AA1MrQK7?ocid=msedgntp&cvid=68ce4014b1fe4953b0b4bd22ef471ab9&ei=78 they feel like they're an amputee in the body of a regular person "For...

Similar threads

Replies
11
Views
27K
Replies
6
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
4K
Back
Top