Discussion Overview
The discussion centers on whether Fortran has a built-in function for calculating the determinant of a matrix. Participants explore the capabilities of Fortran regarding matrix operations, specifically focusing on the absence of direct intrinsic functions for determinants and the reliance on external libraries for such functionality.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Historical
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- Some participants note that Fortran does not have a built-in function for calculating determinants, suggesting that such functionality is typically provided by external libraries like IMSL.
- One participant mentions the intrinsic matrix functions available in Fortran 90, which include MATMUL, TRANSPOSE, and DOT_PRODUCT, but does not include determinant calculations.
- Another participant references historical context, stating that libraries have been used since the 1960s and 1970s for numerical calculations, highlighting the IBM Scientific Subroutine Package and the IMSL library.
- Some participants discuss the evolution of numerical libraries, mentioning that LINPACK and EISPACK were merged into LAPACK, which is now a standard for linear algebra operations.
- There is a viewpoint that keeping mathematical functions as part of external libraries rather than intrinsic to the language allows for greater flexibility and the ability to share libraries across different programming languages.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally agree that Fortran does not include a built-in function for calculating determinants and that external libraries are necessary for this functionality. However, there is a discussion about the implications of this design choice, with differing opinions on the benefits of intrinsic versus external library functions.
Contextual Notes
Participants mention various historical libraries and their purposes, indicating a range of specialized needs that have been addressed over time. The discussion reflects on the evolution of numerical techniques and the role of libraries in programming practices.