Does the difference in charge play a role in electromagnetism such as

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the role of charge differences in electromagnetism, specifically how varying charge magnitudes affect attraction between charges. It emphasizes that the strength of the force is determined by the product of the charges, as described by Coulomb's law, rather than the difference in their values. For example, a +8 charge and a -1 charge exert twice the force of a +4 charge and a -1 charge due to their product being greater. Participants clarify that attraction is calculated by multiplying the charges, leading to a direct correlation with the force experienced. Understanding this principle is crucial for grasping the fundamentals of electromagnetism.
cam875
Messages
227
Reaction score
0
does the difference in charge play a role in electromagnetism such as a +8 charge pulling a -1 being stronger because of the difference in numbers or does that even matter i mean would that mean that that is stronger compared to a + 1 charge pulling a -1 charge. Thanks in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org


Yes, it matters: F=kq1q2/r2

It might be interesting to consider the motion of a test charge between two infinitely large parallel conductors. Does (+1,-1) and (+2,0) produce the same result?

I'm not sure I've that up correctly, but take a look at the method of images:
http://farside.ph.utexas.edu/teaching/em/lectures/node64.html
 
Coulomb's law

cam875 said:
does the difference in charge play a role in electromagnetism such as a +8 charge pulling a -1 being stronger because of the difference in numbers or does that even matter i mean would that mean that that is stronger compared to a + 1 charge pulling a -1 charge. Thanks in advance.

Hi cam875!

It's not the difference in charge, but the product of the charges, that matters (and also the distance, of course :wink:).

So a +8 and a -1 (or a -8 and a +1) pull each other twice as strongly as a +4 and a -1.

See Coulomb's law :smile:
 


cool thanks for the help very interesting. so are u saying that because (+8) + (-1) is 7 and (+4) + (-1) is 3 that there is a little more than double the attraction in the first example.
 
Last edited:


tiny-tim said:
It's not the difference in charge, but the product of the charges, that matters (and also the distance, of course :wink:).

So a +8 and a -1 (or a -8 and a +1) pull each other twice as strongly as a +4 and a -1.

See Coulomb's law :smile:

cam875 said:
cool thanks for the help very interesting. so are u saying that because (+8) + (-1) is 7 and (+4) + (-1) is 3 that there is a little more than double the attraction in the first example.

No. I believe what tiny-tim is very correctly saying is in the first example, the attraction between two point charges a fixed distance apart ~(+8)(-1)=-8 units, in the second example, the attraction is ~(+4)(-1)=-4 units. So the attraction is exactly double in the first example compared to the second.

I really second his recommendation that you look up Coulomb's law.:smile:
 
atyy atyy atyy!

I agree entirely with atyy. :biggrin:
 


oh ok so your multiplying the charges instead of adding them. makes sense and I am going to look at that law, thanks for the help.
 
Back
Top