Does this exist (proximity circuit)?

  • Thread starter Thread starter IHateMayonnaise
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Circuit
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around the concept of a proximity circuit, specifically a system consisting of a stationary "homing beacon" that broadcasts a signal and a device that detects the signal within a limited range. Participants explore various technologies and approaches for creating such a system, including Bluetooth and RFID, while considering practical applications and legal implications.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant suggests using a garage door opener system with unregulated low power bands for a simple solution.
  • Another participant proposes Bluetooth as a more sophisticated option, citing a prototype for a 'man overboard' system that alerts when a device goes out of range.
  • Concerns are raised about the need for the system to activate an alarm when the device moves beyond a specified distance, emphasizing that it should not function beyond that range.
  • RFID is introduced as a potential solution, with distinctions made between passive and active RFID systems based on their detection ranges.
  • Participants discuss the feasibility and costs associated with fabricating RFID systems, including references to specific products and manufacturers.
  • One participant mentions the possibility of using sonar modules as an alternative detection method.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express various viewpoints on the technologies and methods to achieve the desired proximity detection, with no consensus reached on a single solution. Multiple competing ideas, such as Bluetooth, RFID, and sonar, are presented without resolution.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the importance of signal range and reliability, as well as the legal considerations regarding the use of broadcasting devices. There is also mention of the need for varying signal intensity for testing purposes.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for hobbyists, engineers, or individuals interested in developing proximity detection systems for personal use or specific applications such as theft prevention or child monitoring.

IHateMayonnaise
Messages
87
Reaction score
0
More than likely somebody has already done this, however I do not know what to search for or where to start. Hopefully I can find some insight here.

I am looking for some sort of proximity circuit. Specifically, it should consist of two separate components: A "homing beacon," i.e. a stationary circuit broadcasting some signal, and a device that picks it up when it is in range. Both should be battery powered. It needn't work over large distances..say more than about a couple feet or so. Has this been done before? And also, is it legal (from the FCC's perspective) to have this system for my own personal use? Thanks all!

IHateMayonnaise
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
It's fairly easy to do with a garage door opener system using one of the unregulated low power bands (eg 419Mhz)

For a bit more money but less work you can use an off the shelf system like BlueTooth where the base would automatically notify you if a new client had come into range.
I worked on a protoype 'man overboard' system using BlueTooth where the base constantly pinged all it's clients (attached to each crew member) and set an alarm if one of them couldn't be contacted - presumably because it had gone out of range or had stopped transmitting.
It's was the only offshore system where making it fail when immersed in sea water was a design goal!
 
mgb_phys said:
It's fairly easy to do with a garage door opener system using one of the unregulated low power bands (eg 419Mhz)

For a bit more money but less work you can use an off the shelf system like BlueTooth where the base would automatically notify you if a new client had come into range.
I worked on a protoype 'man overboard' system using BlueTooth where the base constantly pinged all it's clients (attached to each crew member) and set an alarm if one of them couldn't be contacted - presumably because it had gone out of range or had stopped transmitting.
It's was the only offshore system where making it fail when immersed in sea water was a design goal!

That's cool, thanks for the thoughtful reply!

Bluetooth sounds pretty much perfect, except that it's a bit overkill. It only needs to work for a couple feet, and outside of this it's actually important that it doesn't work. Here is the big picture: if the traveling device moves more than two feet (more or less...doesn't need to be exact) from the transmitter, it activates another circuit. Sort of like an alarm.

I understand that the transmitted distance depends on obstacles, atmospheric conditions, etc.., but then again the distance sensitivity doesn't have to be perfect - it just needs to do something if it moves more than 2 or 5 or 8 feet away. A good idea would be to be able to vary the intensity of the signal, so this can be tested. Also, if anyone has a better idea of how to achieve this goal, please, share. This is the first thing I thought of so I'm going with it.
 
IHateMayonnaise said:
That's cool, thanks for the thoughtful reply!

Bluetooth sounds pretty much perfect, except that it's a bit overkill. It only needs to work for a couple feet, and outside of this it's actually important that it doesn't work. Here is the big picture: if the traveling device moves more than two feet (more or less...doesn't need to be exact) from the transmitter, it activates another circuit. Sort of like an alarm.

I understand that the transmitted distance depends on obstacles, atmospheric conditions, etc.., but then again the distance sensitivity doesn't have to be perfect - it just needs to do something if it moves more than 2 or 5 or 8 feet away. A good idea would be to be able to vary the intensity of the signal, so this can be tested. Also, if anyone has a better idea of how to achieve this goal, please, share. This is the first thing I thought of so I'm going with it.

How about a shock collar? :smile:

CS
 
That was the idea behind the BlueTooth man-overboard, it was intrinsically fail safe since if it failed or lost signal that was the alarm. If you are doing a theft prevention or child-wandering-off type system you need to think along similair lines. Where the loss of signal is the alert rather.

Do you need to track multiple independent clients from one base station? If so you either need different frequencies or to send some sort of ID data.
Take a look at the Atmel AVR micro, there is an rf data example in the dev kit - I think it's called the butterfly.
 
IHateMayonnaise said:
I am looking for some sort of proximity circuit. Specifically, it should consist of two separate components: A "homing beacon," i.e. a stationary circuit broadcasting some signal, and a device that picks it up when it is in range. Both should be battery powered. It needn't work over large distances..say more than about a couple feet or so.

Have you looked into RFID? The passive version only detects out to a few inches, but the active/powered versions can detect to several feet.
 
asynchronous13 said:
Have you looked into RFID? The passive version only detects out to a few inches, but the active/powered versions can detect to several feet.

That sounds pretty much exactly what I'm looking for, thanks! How difficult would it be to fabricate one (if they're not too complicated) or about how much would one cost? I am jumping straight to google to see if i can't find these things out, however a second opinion never hurts :)
 
there are 3 types of rfid, passive, semi-active and active. Passive rfid harvest the energy from the coil so it only works when it is close to detect the energy (inches). You will need active rfid. Try digikey.

there's a reader from atmel u2270B, add that with a controller and a tag to read.
 
IHateMayonnaise said:
That sounds pretty much exactly what I'm looking for, thanks! How difficult would it be to fabricate one (if they're not too complicated) or about how much would one cost? I am jumping straight to google to see if i can't find these things out, however a second opinion never hurts :)

For hobby-style RFID check Phidgets or Parallax. Prices from $40 to $65 for the reader, the cards are $1-2 /each (for passive). Active costs more, but I don't know a brand off-hand.
 
  • #10
I think you can still get small sonar modules (they used to be used in cameras).
One of those might work.
Depends on if only identified objects should be detected.
 
  • #11
Thanks for the replies all - I think I found out what I needed. There is actually an RFID device that does exactly what I am looking for - the Gotcha! Child Monitoring System - the parent wears a device and if the child travels outside a predefined radius it beeps incessantly. Thanks for the help everyone!
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
5K
Replies
20
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
13K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
4K
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K