Electric field of point charge within spherical shell.

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
5 replies · 4K views
malignant
Messages
40
Reaction score
1
If there was a spherical shell with negative charge density and a positive point charge inside the shell, the electric field lines from the point charge would just be radially outward towards the shell right?

What about the case where there's a positive charge density and a positive point charge? I'm having trouble conceptualizing what happens to the field lines from the point charge then.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
malignant said:
If there was a spherical shell with negative charge density and a positive point charge inside the shell, the electric field lines from the point charge would just be radially outward towards the shell right?
Do you mean a hollow shell with a uniformly distributed negative charge? Then yes.

malignant said:
What about the case where there's a positive charge density and a positive point charge? I'm having trouble conceptualizing what happens to the field lines from the point charge then.
Ask yourself: What field does the shell's charge contribute inside the shell?
 
Isn't the field inside from the shell's charge zero leaving just the field from the point charge? Or would the field from the shell and the point charge have to be summed?
 
malignant said:
Isn't the field inside from the shell's charge zero leaving just the field from the point charge?
Yes.

malignant said:
Or would the field from the shell and the point charge have to be summed?
Yes. (But the field from the shell is zero. ;))
 
Ok but where do the field lines go from the point charge? If it doesn't escape the shell due to the positive charge on the shell repelling, and no lines can intersect, it sounds like the field would end up being infinitely dense.
 
malignant said:
Ok but where do the field lines go from the point charge? If it doesn't escape the shell due to the positive charge on the shell repelling, and no lines can intersect, it sounds like the field would end up being infinitely dense.
Outside the shell, the field will be the sum of the fields from the point charge and from the shell. (The field from the shell is zero within the shell, but not outside the shell.)