Electric Fields in Faraday cages

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the behavior of electric fields and electromagnetic waves in the context of Faraday cages. Participants explore hypothetical scenarios involving charged objects and the effects of enclosing them within conductive materials, focusing on both theoretical implications and practical applications.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant poses a hypothetical scenario about a charged object generating an electric field and questions whether a Faraday cage would prevent any fields or waves from escaping.
  • Another participant suggests that, aside from some leakage, field lines would terminate at the cage, and induced currents could potentially be harnessed for heating or powering devices.
  • A later reply introduces the idea that if a perfect superconducting Faraday cage were used, no static or dynamic fields would exist inside it, though this is contrasted with the reality of typical conductive cages.
  • Participants discuss the possibility of using a metal pop-can as a Faraday cage and whether it could convert electromagnetic waves into current, with references to antenna theory and the behavior of electrons in conductors.
  • There is mention of the limitations of real Faraday cages, including the potential for electric fields to exist outside the cage under certain conditions, particularly in static situations as described by Gauss's Law.
  • Some participants express uncertainty about the complete effectiveness of Faraday cages in blocking electromagnetic waves, suggesting that there may be some current induced but not a total blockage of fields.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the effectiveness of Faraday cages in blocking electric fields and electromagnetic waves. While some agree that currents can be induced within the cage, others argue that there may still be fields present outside, indicating a lack of consensus on the topic.

Contextual Notes

There are unresolved assumptions regarding the ideal conditions for Faraday cages, such as the distinction between perfect conductors and real materials, as well as the implications of static versus dynamic electromagnetic fields.

caybo
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Lets say, hypothetically of course, that i know somebody that had something that, with that something being charged, was generating a strong electric field(or maybe electromagnetic waves?) that was emitted in all directions for infinity, if this hypothetical friend were to put a faraday cage around the said object, would there be any field, or waves(answer for both please :approve:) outside of the cage, and if not where would they be, and if they were diverted, would there be a way to, (for lack of better words) to capture or harness, said electromagnetism, and use it?
(P.S. This is not a homework question, I am actually very curious thank you very much!)o:)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Apart from a bit of leakage, all the field lines would end at the metal of the cage. There would be currents induced in the metal of the cage.
These currents could be used to heat the cage or even drive a motor.
 
Thanks, Thats so Awesome, I can't wait to try it out! Youve been an enormous help :smile:
 
caybo said:
Thanks, Thats so Awesome, I can't wait to try it out! Youve been an enormous help :smile:

What kind of answer were you expecting then ?
 
vanesch said:
What kind of answer were you expecting then ?

Well... I wasn't being sarcastic! He gave me the exact answer i wanted :smile:

So this type of answer was Perfect
Meir Achuz said:
Apart from a bit of leakage, all the field lines would end at the metal of the cage. There would be currents induced in the metal of the cage.
These currents could be used to heat the cage or even drive a motor.
 
caybo said:
Lets say, hypothetically of course, that i know somebody that had something that, with that something being charged, was generating a strong electric field(or maybe electromagnetic waves?) that was emitted in all directions for infinity, if this hypothetical friend were to put a faraday cage around the said object, would there be any field, or waves(answer for both please :approve:) outside of the cage, and if not where would they be, and if they were diverted, would there be a way to, (for lack of better words) to capture or harness, said electromagnetism, and use it?
(P.S. This is not a homework question, I am actually very curious thank you very much!)o:)
Were the faraday cage a true closed superconductor then no,there would be no static fields or dynamic EM fields inside it (both theoreticaly and practically).
In reality there are usually no superconducting faraday cages but only very well conducting metal cages.And small magnetic fields and EM fields might be present inside it but attenuations of the fields are very considerable.
Of course,there is an interesting situation when a hypotheical friend encloses the door of the superconducting box placed in the dynamic EM field.
That action may capture EM waves inside such box,with eternal wave reflection from the internal walls ...
 
Last edited:
OK Help Again please

Ive come back for continuation of help from the previous problem. This time, instead of leaving quite so much ambiguity, i Will be more specific, but in one detail.
Ok, again with the hypothetical thing producing EM waves in all directions. And let's say I stuck a metal pop-can around it. Would the can turn the EM waves into current? if so how would I use the current? If it was current wouldn't it have to be going somewhere, instead of stuck in the can? Would there be, say someway to use it to power an LED or something low current?

If the can wouldn't can't turn it to current is there some way I can?
Is there some way that I can detect if there is any EM waves emmitted from the thing producing EM waves? I need to know this stuff. thanks guys :wink:
 
caybo said:
And let's say I stuck a metal pop-can around it. Would the can turn the EM waves into current? if so how would I use the current? If it was current wouldn't it have to be going somewhere, instead of stuck in the can?

Yes,it would.
Think of antenna theory :radio receivers, TV sets ...
What do you think how these devices pick EM signals ?:wink:
 
caybo said:
Ive come back for continuation of help from the previous problem. This time, instead of leaving quite so much ambiguity, i Will be more specific, but in one detail.
Ok, again with the hypothetical thing producing EM waves in all directions. And let's say I stuck a metal pop-can around it. Would the can turn the EM waves into current? if so how would I use the current? If it was current wouldn't it have to be going somewhere, instead of stuck in the can? Would there be, say someway to use it to power an LED or something low current?
The thing is that your faraday cage, or the metal can, are conductors, i.e. there are freely moving electrons inside the material. Now, if you subject those electrons to an electric field, they will move around according to the field applied and thereby try to counter the electric field (because they will try to reach static equilibrium). This motion of the electrons inside the conductor is what has been referred to as current.
But be careful: If you try to make the electrons go somewhere else, that is leaving the conductor, you're in for trouble.
 
  • #10
Time I mentioned the perfect faraday cage again: a cake tin.
 
  • #11
Meir Achuz said:
Apart from a bit of leakage, all the field lines would end at the metal of the cage. There would be currents induced in the metal of the cage.
These currents could be used to heat the cage or even drive a motor.

If I remember correctly, I do not think this is the case. Set up a problem where you have an uncharged sperical metal shell (your faraday cage) and a charged object in the center. Now if you use Gauss's Law, you'll see that in fact there will be an electric field outside your cage. This is for the static situation.

For the case of electromagnetic waves, you will get a little current in the cage while the electrons rearrange themselves to cancel out the field within the cage, but it shouldn't completely block all the field from going outside the cage
 
  • #12
ursubaloo said:
If I remember correctly, I do not think this is the case. Set up a problem where you have an uncharged sperical metal shell (your faraday cage) and a charged object in the center. Now if you use Gauss's Law, you'll see that in fact there will be an electric field outside your cage. This is for the static situation.

For the case of electromagnetic waves, you will get a little current in the cage while the electrons rearrange themselves to cancel out the field within the cage, but it shouldn't completely block all the field from going outside the cage
If there is net charge inside the cage, there will be a static E field outside the cage (by Gauss), but no time dependence. This assumes a perfect conductor. For a conductor with finite conductance, there will be leakage of the time dependent fields for high enough frequency.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
11K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 41 ·
2
Replies
41
Views
7K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
3K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
2K