- #1

- 17

- 0

This might be an off topic question but, since there are a lot of engineers and physicists here, i'll ask.

What are the requirements for an electronics or electrical engineering major, can I be an engineer if I always sucked at math at school?.

I've always had this doubt, since I dont know if I have what it takes, but I think I dont, I've seen a lot of engineering dropouts, and they all share one common thing: they sucked at math and physics since high school.

I dropped out of my engineering career some time ago because I had no money and my grades were embarrasing, but now I'm working (and therefore i've saved enough money) and I think I can go back to the university, but after several thoughts I dont think I have what it takes to be an electronic engineer, since I suck at math, and I might end up just wasting money and time in a career that requires much more than my current capabilites.

One of my friends its about to finish his engineering major, he has great grades, and he barely goes to classes, he barely asks questions to the teachers, or writes in his notebook, he says to me that he always deduces or figures out all those formulaes or equations instead of memoryzing them and reads in the books to learn what he dont learn in the classes that he often misses. I dont get how can he deduce a transfer function or complex ODE's or almost every derivative rule, but since can simplify and solve equations almost " naturally", my best guess was: he was born to be an engineer.

I tryed to do the same, and decided to learn ODEs by my own, and I still cant get a thing (from Stewart's book), I get the mechanical process (you derive, you replace in the main function, and check if the solution satisfies it) but I dont get I.E. what is dy/du, I cant deduce the equations or apply logic to solve math problems just like my friend does.

Everybody always say "dont ever give up" or " everybody is different" but whats the point if you just cant understand a simple math problem that other people understood easily?, I think that you need some "math-ready" mind to fully understand the concepts and then become a good engineer, I think you cant be an engineer if you dont have that " math-ready" or "logic-ready" instinct inside your mind, since math and engineering problems are NOT always things that you can do by performing always the same steps, you have to figure some solutions by your own.

So what attitudes or IQ or whatever do you think that the people needs in order to study (and get good grades) engineering?.