Electrons: Wave & Particle Movement Explained

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter brian.green
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Electrons
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
3 replies · 2K views
brian.green
Messages
26
Reaction score
2
What keep electrons move? I read somewhere that in q physics the kinetic energy of an electron mean how much the wave cloud is compressed. If the electron is part of an atom its wave is wide a smeared but if delocalized then its wave is small and its position much more exact.
But the electron can move/flow in a conductor. That's different moving? It has two kind of "moving"?
And this classical moving also constant, e- always move as a wave and as a particle too?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
electron always move?
No. As an example, electrons in an atom do not move (with a few irrelevant exceptions). They have a kinetic energy, but this is nothing like motion in the classical sense.
But if they move, without an external force they will keep moving - what would stop them?
brian.green said:
I read somewhere that in q physics the kinetic energy of an electron mean how much the wave cloud is compressed.
That does not make sense.
brian.green said:
And this classical moving also constant, e- always move as a wave and as a particle too?
Electrons are quantum objects, they are neither wave nor particle, although those descriptions can be useful sometimes.
 
mfb said:
But if they move, without an external force they will keep moving - what would stop them?

If we have a piece of metal, there is delocalized electrons on its surface. These electrons are moving or not? If moving then radiating EM energy and loose kinetic energy, finally stop moving. This would stop them.
But if not move how can the changing magnetic field accelerate them? So called circular current induced but how? They are rest and cannot sense magnetic force.

And there is the explanation (first answer) of electron wave compression and quantum kinetic energy what I said:
https://van.physics.illinois.edu/qa/listing.php?id=1195
 
Last edited:
brian.green said:
If we have a piece of metal, there is delocalized electrons on its surface.
Not only there.
brian.green said:
These electrons are moving or not?
They can, it depends on the setup.
brian.green said:
If moving then radiating EM energy
Not if they move in a straight line, neglecting collisions with defects.
brian.green said:
But if not move how can the changing magnetic field accelerate them? So called circular current induced but how? They are rest and cannot sense magnetic force.
The classical picture doesn't work well here. They have a momentum distribution, and the magnetic field acts on this distribution.
brian.green said:
nd there is the explanation (first answer) of electron wave compression and quantum kinetic energy what I said:
That is not what you said. A more localized electron has a larger spread in momentum, it does not need to have a larger momentum. Turning that around makes it even worse, because a large momentum or even a large spread in momentum tells us nothing about the localization in space.