Find current with source transforms

17 replies · 2K views · last reply
eehelp150
Messages
235
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Circuit schematic with a current source labelled 3 ∠30° A in parallel with a capacitor of -j3 Ω, a 4 Ω resistor, and then a j4 Ω inductor in series, a -j2 Ω capacitor, and a 2 Ω resistor with current I marked downward.


Homework Equations


V=IR

The Attempt at a Solution


First I combined the -j3 capacitor and 4ohm resistor to get:
[tex]\frac{32-j48}{25}[/tex].
Then I combined that with the j4 ohm inductor to get:
[tex]\frac{32+j52}{25}[/tex].
Then I combined that with the -j2 ohm capacitor to get:
[tex]\frac{104-72j}{36+j2}[/tex]
My circuit now looks something like:
Circuit schematic with a current source labeled 3 angle 30 A feeding a ladder network of -j3 ohm capacitor, 4 ohm resistor, j4 ohm inductor, and -j2 ohm capacitor, with a 2 ohm resistor on the right carrying current I. A red box outlines the middle network and a red note reads 104-72j over 36+j2.


I then transform the Current Source into a voltage source:
3<30° -> [tex]\frac{3\sqrt{3}}{2} + 1.5i[/tex]
Z total = [tex]\frac{36-28j}{13}[/tex]
V=I * Z = [tex]\frac{84+103\sqrt3}{26} + \frac{54-84sqrt3j}{26}[/tex]

I now have something like this:
Circuit schematic with a voltage source V1 on the left, an impedance labelled Z=(36-28j)/13 in series on top, and resistor R1 of 2 ohms on the right.

Have I been doing everything right so far? How do I find I?
 
eehelp150 said:

The Attempt at a Solution


First I combined the -j3 capacitor and 4ohm resistor to get:
[tex]\frac{32-j48}{25}[/tex].
You might want to check that result.

As you "absorb" components you must modify the source value, too. Effectively you are converting between current and voltage sources as you progress, doing a Norton → Thevenin → Norton shuffle.
 
gneill said:
You might want to check that result.

As you "absorb" components you must modify the source value, too. Effectively you are converting between current and voltage sources as you progress, doing a Norton → Thevenin → Norton shuffle.
What is wrong with the result? Am I not supposed to combine those two parts?
 
eehelp150 said:
What is wrong with the result? Am I not supposed to combine those two parts?
No, combining them is fine. Check your calculated result.
 
eehelp150 said:

The Attempt at a Solution


First I combined the -j3 capacitor and 4ohm resistor to get:
[tex]\frac{32-j48}{25}[/tex].
Then I combined that with the j4 ohm inductor to get:
[tex]\frac{32+j52}{25}[/tex].
Then I combined that with the -j2 ohm capacitor to get:
[tex]\frac{104-72j}{36+j2}[/tex]

The two steps in red are where you made your mistake. You must combine the j4 and -j2 in series, and then that equivalent combines in parallel with what you have up to that point.
 
The Electrician said:
The two steps in red are where you made your mistake. You must combine the j4 and -j2 in series, and then that equivalent combines in parallel with what you have up to that point.
Circuit schematic: current source I1 labelled 3<30 on the left, feeding a parallel network of R1 and Z3 in the middle and R3 (2ohm) on the right, with an arrow marking the current through R3.

this is what my circuit looks like now, with Z3 = (96-72j)/(36+2j)
Everything good?
how do I solve for current I
 
Not good. Your current source has to evolve as you absorb the components. Think of it as taking successive Thevenin or Norton equivalents as you go.

You started by reducing the -j3 capacitor and 4 Ohm resistor to a single impedance, then took it and the current source as a Norton model. All good so far. Then you wanted to absorb the j4 inductor. To do that you have to convert the Norton circuit into its Thevenin equivalent first. So the Norton impedance becomes the series impedance for the Thevenin model and you also have to convert the current source to a Thevenin voltage by multiplying it by that impedance. Then you can include the j4 inductor. The same thing goes for absorbing the -j2 capacitor. You need to convert your new Thevenin model back to a Norton model (source current and parallel impedance). The original current source will be "buried" behind a set of multipliers that it accumulates during the switching back and forth between model types.

Your first change of source goes like this:
Circuit schematic with a voltage source labelled Vth, Zth and I0·z1 in series with z1, then j4 Ω inductor and -j2 Ω capacitor; below it z1 = (-j·3)·(4) / (-j·3 + 4) = 36/25 - 48/25·j.
 
gneill said:
Not good. Your current source has to evolve as you absorb the components. Think of it as taking successive Thevenin or Norton equivalents as you go.

You started by reducing the -j3 capacitor and 4 Ohm resistor to a single impedance, then took it and the current source as a Norton model. All good so far. Then you wanted to absorb the j4 inductor. To do that you have to convert the Norton circuit into its Thevenin equivalent first. So the Norton impedance becomes the series impedance for the Thevenin model and you also have to convert the current source to a Thevenin voltage by multiplying it by that impedance. Then you can include the j4 inductor. The same thing goes for absorbing the -j2 capacitor. You need to convert your new Thevenin model back to a Norton model (source current and parallel impedance). The original current source will be "buried" behind a set of multipliers that it accumulates during the switching back and forth between model types.

Your first change of source goes like this:
View attachment 107409
Circuit schematic with a current source labelled I1, with arrow pointing up, in parallel with two resistors labelled R1 and R2 and an impedance labelled Z, with a second element labelled 2 beside R2.


I = 4.47515-2.2127j
Z = (4-72j)/(36-48j)

To get the current, can I use a current divider here or do I need another conversion?
I ended up getting
I = 1.32 - 1.44i
 
Last edited:
Practically speaking you can do it either way. If they are expecting you to use source changes though, you might want to follow through to the end.

You should check your results using another method when you're done. Perhaps using Nodal analysis.
 
gneill said:
Practically speaking you can do it either way. If they are expecting you to use source changes though, you might want to follow through to the end.

You should check your results using another method when you're done. Perhaps using Nodal analysis.
I ended up getting
1.32 - 1.44i Amps
 
eehelp150 said:
I ended up getting
1.32 - 1.44i Amps
Not what I'm seeing. I did the whole series of source changes down to a final Thevenin model in series with the 2 Ohm load, and I checked using nodal analysis to find the voltage at the output node then determined the current through the load from that. The results agreed, and they weren't the same as your result above :frown:
 
gneill said:
Not what I'm seeing. I did the whole series of source changes down to a final Thevenin model in series with the 2 Ohm load, and I checked using nodal analysis to find the voltage at the output node then determined the current through the load from that. The results agreed, and they weren't the same as your result above :frown:
My Vth is 3-5.2i
is that off as well?
 
gneill said:
Not what I'm seeing. I did the whole series of source changes down to a final Thevenin model in series with the 2 Ohm load, and I checked using nodal analysis to find the voltage at the output node then determined the current through the load from that. The results agreed, and they weren't the same as your result above :frown:
Is it right up to here?
Circuit schematic: a current source labelled I1 with an arrow, in parallel with resistor R1 in series with impedance Z, and resistor R2 in series with impedance Z2, with the lower node labelled I.


I = 4.47515-2.2127j
Z = (4-72j)/(36-48j)
 
I don't believe so, no. In that configuration your Z should match my final Thevenin impedance and it doesn't.

Your Z:
Handwritten fraction (4 - 72·1j)/(36 - 48·1j) equals 1 - 0.667j, shown as a worked calculation of a complex impedance.


Mine:
Handwritten expression Z th = 2.769 - 2.154j with a small subscript th on Z.
 
eehelp150 said:
So your Z is 2.769 - 2.154j at the point in my picture?

That would be my understanding, yes.

Perhaps we need to go through the transformations one at a time from the beginning?
 
gneill said:
That would be my understanding, yes.

Perhaps we need to go through the transformations one at a time from the beginning?
I know where I screwed up.
Final I should be:
-0.067 - 1.9i A
 
eehelp150 said:
I know where I screwed up.
Final I should be:
-0.067 - 1.9i A
Yes, that looks good. :approve: