For what time does an electron move after current turned off?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the confusion regarding the movement of electrons in a wire after current is turned off. It clarifies that when current is zero, drift velocity is also zero, meaning there is no net movement of electrons. The transition from current to no current is not instantaneous and involves a waveform, with the current gradually dying down. Additionally, it is noted that electrons in a metal do not stop moving entirely due to thermal motion, with a rough estimate of the relaxation time being around 10^-15 seconds. The question posed is deemed vague, complicating the physics being discussed.
bananabandana
Messages
112
Reaction score
5
Hi,
Can someone point me in the right direction in terms of calculating the length of time an electron in a wire would continue to move after the current is turned off?
Can we use the drift velocity in some way?
Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The electron movement is the current in the wire so I'm not sure what you mean "after the current is turned off".
 
You want the impulse or step responce for the circuit... For the DC case, where you are opening a switch from a voltage source at t=0, the signal is v(t)=V(1-u(t)).

This will tell you how the current dies down.

On the scale of individual electrons, they never stop moving.
 
bananabandana said:
Hi,
Can someone point me in the right direction in terms of calculating the length of time an electron in a wire would continue to move after the current is turned off?
Can we use the drift velocity in some way?
Thanks!
Current is zero: drift velocity is zero.
There is no (real) circuit in which the current can stop instantly (a step); the transition from current to no current will always take time and there will be a waveform - perhaps a slow change or it may involve 'ringing' as the current goes to zero. Simon Bridge's post says that, in a more formal way.
 
Thanks. What are u(t) [\tex] and v(t) [\tex] please?
 
V and I are voltages and currents that do not vary with time.
v and i are voltages and currents that do vary with time.

v(t) just says "voltage as a function of time".
u(t) is the unit (or Heaviside) step function.

So ##v(t)=Vu(t)## just says that the voltage was switched on at time t=0, and ##v(t)=V\big(1-u(t)\big)## says that the voltage V was switched off at time t=0
 
There's something rather odd about this thread.

First of all, if one pays attention to the original post, there's something not quite right with the way the question is being asked. As nsaspook has stated, "current" is the net movement of electrons. So if the current is "turned off", then there's no net movement! That's like asking "how fast am I moving if my speed is zero?" Did the OP meant potential difference?

Secondly, at first glance, one would want to answer this in a simplistic, elementary picture. But then, the concept of "drift velocity" is brought in. And from my perspective, I start to question if the OP understands the statistical nature of the electron gas in metals (remember, the question is about electron movement in a wire!). If so, then the simplistic, elementary picture isn't sufficient, because at a finite temperature, electrons simply don't stop moving, and so the answer to the question of when electrons stop moving after the potential difference is zero is NEVER.

When the question is vague and faulty, and the scenario and level of the question is unknown, then the question becomes a bigger puzzle than the actual physics being asked.

Zz.
 
  • Like
Likes Nugatory
Maybe a rough estimate would be the relaxation time (τ) used in free electron gas models. (like Drude's model)
In metals the electrons "loose" their drift component due to thermal motion in a time of the order of 10^(-15) s.
 
Back
Top