Gas Expansion and Temperature Change in PE Exam

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around gas expansion and temperature change, particularly in the context of preparing for the PE exam. Participants explore various equations and methodologies related to thermal expansion, Joule-Thomson expansion, and the application of equations of state.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant discusses a differential equation related to temperature change with respect to pressure, expressing frustration over the direction of temperature change obtained from their calculations.
  • Another participant mentions working on thermal expansion of methanol alongside Joule-Thomson expansion, noting unexpected temperature trends and difficulties in deriving an equation for final temperature in terms of pressure change.
  • There is a query about the meaning of "Vr" in the context of an Otto cycle, with a participant seeking clarification on its definition and application.
  • One participant suggests that using an equation of state in its original format might be a better approach, questioning the utility of the Joule-Thomson coefficient in this context.
  • Participants share their experiences with the PE exam and express a desire for more clarity on specific calculations and methodologies.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express various viewpoints and uncertainties regarding the methodologies for calculating temperature changes and the implications of using different equations of state. There is no consensus on the best approach or resolution to the issues raised.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention limitations in their understanding of certain concepts, such as the integrating factor in differential equations and the assumptions underlying their calculations. There are also references to specific resources, such as air tables and the chemical engineering PE exam book, which may not be universally familiar.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals preparing for the PE exam, particularly those focused on thermodynamics, gas expansion, and related calculations, may find this discussion relevant.

rppearso
Messages
196
Reaction score
3
I have been working on a series of questions dealing with gas expansion and temperature change for my PE exam.

[tex]\frac{}{}[/tex]
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
rppearso said:
I have been working on a series of questions dealing with gas expansion and temperature change for my PE exam.

[tex]\frac{}{}[/tex]

sorry having trouble with the latex thing so I am just going to type it out,

dT/dP = 1/mCp(2a/RT - b) when I take the Bernoulli differential equation of this I get the following:

T2= (C1/C2 + c/exp(2*C2*P2))^.5 Where C1 = 2*a/m*Cp*R and C2 = b/m*Cp

where c is solved for using the intital conditions of T1 and P1

This equation is dependent upon mass, but also I am getting the temperature going in the wrong direction, this is very frustrating because I am trying to come up with a rigourus way of solving for T2 without using the fishy method they use in the PE solution manual where they iterate and practically guess a mass loss/gain in or out of the bottle.
 
I am kinda working the thermal expansion of methanol in tandum with joule thompson expansion. I am studying for my PE right now (along with doing that thermal expansion of methanol at work) and I am having the same set of problems dealing with air, I attempted to use joule thompson to model rapid expansion of gas (the calcs under methanol expansion actually apply more to joule thompson rather than liquid expansion). If you view the work I did attached to thermal expansion of methanol (and I will also attach the mathcad and updated hand calcs) you will see that you get temperature trends opposite of what is expected and after going through the first law derivation and a bernoulli differential equation its pretty frustrating because it should be correct for the rapid expansion of a gas, I was doing this in order to develop an equation for T2 in terms of pressure change using a vander walls equation of state.

All that being said I need to progress with my PE study so I have just been using the air tables at the back of the PE book but I am not sure what Vr actually is. In an otto cycle in the constant volume expansion V is constant from D to A but Vr is not what exactly is Vr, we never used air tables in college and while I can crank out the PE problems using the methods in the book I would really like to know what it is I am doing.

This has been a very good site and I am glad I found it, it keeps me doing things that are useful and more away from political sites which just waste your time.

I have the updated joule thompson calcs worked out using the bernoulli differential equation (the roots of the methodology of solving first order non seperable differential equations will have to wait another day in a different section, but what is up with the integrating factor and why can you assume the constant of integration goes away, among other questions) and I will post them as soon as I can consolidate my work and scan everything in.
 
rppearso said:
I am kinda working the thermal expansion of methanol in tandum with joule thompson expansion. I am studying for my PE right now (along with doing that thermal expansion of methanol at work) and I am having the same set of problems dealing with air, I attempted to use joule thompson to model rapid expansion of gas (the calcs under methanol expansion actually apply more to joule thompson rather than liquid expansion). If you view the work I did attached to thermal expansion of methanol (and I will also attach the mathcad and updated hand calcs) you will see that you get temperature trends opposite of what is expected and after going through the first law derivation and a bernoulli differential equation its pretty frustrating because it should be correct for the rapid expansion of a gas, I was doing this in order to develop an equation for T2 in terms of pressure change using a vander walls equation of state.

All that being said I need to progress with my PE study so I have just been using the air tables at the back of the PE book but I am not sure what Vr actually is. In an otto cycle in the constant volume expansion V is constant from D to A but Vr is not what exactly is Vr, we never used air tables in college and while I can crank out the PE problems using the methods in the book I would really like to know what it is I am doing.

This has been a very good site and I am glad I found it, it keeps me doing things that are useful and more away from political sites which just waste your time.

I have the updated joule thompson calcs worked out using the bernoulli differential equation (the roots of the methodology of solving first order non seperable differential equations will have to wait another day in a different section, but what is up with the integrating factor and why can you assume the constant of integration goes away, among other questions) and I will post them as soon as I can consolidate my work and scan everything in.

Vr generally stands for Reduced Volume (i.e. The ratio of the specific volume of a substance to its critical volume). Not sure without seeing the book you are reading though.

CS
 
stewartcs said:
Vr generally stands for Reduced Volume (i.e. The ratio of the specific volume of a substance to its critical volume). Not sure without seeing the book you are reading though.

CS

It is the chemical engineering PE exam book by professional publications. I have attached my final calcs, it would not allow me to attach xmcd files but this should be enough. The A was put there by another engineer that was looking at it at my desk while I was away from my desk and he was waiting to go to lunch with me, this was just for the first sheet deriving the joule thompson relationship.
 

Attachments

Maybe I am taking an entirely wrong approch to this, maybe I should just be using an equation of state in its original format. However that being said, what would be the purpose of a joule thompson coefficient if you were just using an equation of state to solve for final temperature anyways. I know Hysys will calculate temperature drop through a valve using equations of state because I changed the equations of state and the outlet temperature changed.

I would greatly appreciate any help.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
6K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
4K
  • · Replies 33 ·
2
Replies
33
Views
3K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
6K
  • · Replies 44 ·
2
Replies
44
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K