Good luck, and let me know if you run into any more problems!

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving a momentum problem using the conservation of total momentum equations. The initial attempt incorrectly equates the x and y momentum components to the total momentum, leading to confusion in calculating angles. Participants clarify that the total momentum should be broken down into its x and y components separately. They emphasize the importance of correctly applying trigonometric functions to find the resultant velocity and angle. The conversation concludes with suggestions to ensure all components are accounted for to arrive at the correct solution.
mpittma1
Messages
55
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


https://scontent-a-sjc.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn1/t1.0-9/603671_1409914319284787_3441607163537875560_n.jpg


Homework Equations



conservation of total momentum

M1V1+M2V2 = MtotVf

The Attempt at a Solution



I tried using the COTM

as such:

x: M1V1iCOSΘ1+M2V2SINΘ2=MtotVf

y: M1V1iSINΘ1+M2V2COSΘ2=MtotVf


then dividing 1/2:

COTΘ1 + TANΘ2 = 1

Θ2 = TAN-1(1-COTΘ1)

After plugging in the values I am getting Θ2 = -10.85°

What am I doing wrong?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I think the main issue is in setting both the x and y equations equal to ##M_{tot}V_{f}##, since these are only component equations, so neither will equal the entire momentum. Instead, you'll want to use the components of the total momentum, so ##M_{tot}v_{f,x}## and ##M_{tot}v_{f,y}##
 
jackarms said:
I think the main issue is in setting both the x and y equations equal to ##M_{tot}V_{f}##, since these are only component equations, so neither will equal the entire momentum. Instead, you'll want to use the components of the total momentum, so ##M_{tot}v_{f,x}## and ##M_{tot}v_{f,y}##

I can't see that working because the ending vector is directly along the x-axis, there is no sin or cos involved with that vector.
 
No, it works. The angle from the vertical will just be 0 degrees, so you'll have something like:

##P_{x} = P_{tot} \cdot cos(0)## and
##P_{y} = P_{tot} \cdot sin(0)##
 
jackarms said:
No, it works. The angle from the vertical will just be 0 degrees, so you'll have something like:

##P_{x} = P_{tot} \cdot cos(0)## and
##P_{y} = P_{tot} \cdot sin(0)##

so the equation becomes TANΘ1+COTΘ2=0

Θ2=COT-1(-TANθ1)

Θ2= -.025°
 
Well, you can't divide the equations like that.
$$\frac{a + b}{c + d} \neq \frac{a}{c} + \frac{b}{d}$$
 
jackarms said:
Well, you can't divide the equations like that.
$$\frac{a + b}{c + d} \neq \frac{a}{c} + \frac{b}{d}$$

Ok so before dividing I have

x: M1V1iCOSθ1+M2V2iSINθ2=MtotVfCOS(0)

y: M1V1iSINθ1+M2V2iCOSθ2=MtotVfSIN(0)

look legit?
 
Yes, that looks good. I think the easiest way to solve would be to move the components with ##M_{1}v_{1}## over, and then you could divide the equations.
 
Hey there!

$$V_{total} = \sqrt{V_{x}^2+V_{y}^2}$$

and

$$\theta = tan^{-1}(\frac{V_{y}}{V_{x}})$$

These seem to be the only two equations that you are forgetting about. As long as you can solve for both component of your resultant velocities, you should be good!
 
Back
Top