Guidance on Matrices: Get a Better Understanding with Books/Videos

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on understanding matrices and determinants, particularly the reasoning behind matrix multiplication and the significance of determinants. Matrix multiplication is defined to facilitate notation for systems of linear equations and is fundamentally linked to linear maps, which provide a geometric perspective on the topic. The determinant serves a crucial role in determining the number of solutions to a system of equations and the invertibility of matrices, with geometric interpretations, such as representing the volume of a parallelepiped, enhancing comprehension.Participants recommend resources for deeper understanding, notably "Introduction to Linear Algebra" by Lang for beginners, which includes proofs, and Treil's "Linear Algebra Done Wrong," a more advanced and free resource. The conversation also emphasizes the importance of dedicating time to study matrices and encourages consistent practice to build interest and understanding.
Yashbhatt
Messages
348
Reaction score
13
Hello, I have been studying matrices and determinants recently and do not understand why certain things are done the way they are. Like, why is matrix multiplication defined the way it is.

I find that there are not enough proofs. Is there any book/article/video that any of you recommend to gain a better understanding of matrices and determinants?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
There is a bit of a pedagogical problem when introducing matrices and determinants. They are very useful tools and there are very good reasons to define them the way we do. But it is typically not immediately possible to tell the students about these reasons.

For multiplication of matrices, one preliminary reason could be that it gives us an easier notation to denote systems of linear equations. But the real reason of course is that multiplication of matrices come from a very geometrical object, namely the linear maps. Once you understand linear maps, you'll be convinced of the necessity of the matrix multiplication.

The determinant is a very complicated expression. But it essentially has one primary use, namely that it decides how many solutions a system of equations have. Or equivalently, it decides whether a matrix is invertible or not. There are many geometrical ways of seeing the determinant, a favorite one is that the determinant gives the volume of a parallelepiped.

A good introductory book (with proofs) is "Introduction to Linear Algebra" by Lang (be sure not to get his more advanced "Linear algebra"). https://www.amazon.com/dp/0387962050/?tag=pfamazon01-20
A very very good book (but also more advanced) is Treil's "Linear algebra done wrong": http://www.math.brown.edu/~treil/papers/LADW/LADW.html It is completely free too.
 
  • Like
Likes QuantumCurt and Yashbhatt
micromass said:
There is a bit of a pedagogical problem when introducing matrices and determinants. They are very useful tools and there are very good reasons to define them the way we do. But it is typically not immediately possible to tell the students about these reasons.

For multiplication of matrices, one preliminary reason could be that it gives us an easier notation to denote systems of linear equations. But the real reason of course is that multiplication of matrices come from a very geometrical object, namely the linear maps. Once you understand linear maps, you'll be convinced of the necessity of the matrix multiplication.

The determinant is a very complicated expression. But it essentially has one primary use, namely that it decides how many solutions a system of equations have. Or equivalently, it decides whether a matrix is invertible or not. There are many geometrical ways of seeing the determinant, a favorite one is that the determinant gives the volume of a parallelepiped.

A good introductory book (with proofs) is "Introduction to Linear Algebra" by Lang (be sure not to get his more advanced "Linear algebra"). https://www.amazon.com/dp/0387962050/?tag=pfamazon01-20
A very very good book (but also more advanced) is Treil's "Linear algebra done wrong": http://www.math.brown.edu/~treil/papers/LADW/LADW.html It is completely free too.

Thanks. I'll try them. How advanced are linear maps?
 
Yashbhatt said:
Thanks. I'll try them. How advanced are linear maps?

Depends on which book you read. But most introductory books treat them rather well. They should be easy once you realize that they are nothing more than generalization of very familiar things: rotations, reflections, etc.
 
micromass said:
The determinant is a very complicated expression. But it essentially has one primary use, namely that it decides how many solutions a system of equations have. Or equivalently, it decides whether a matrix is invertible or not. There are many geometrical ways of seeing the determinant, a favorite one is that the determinant gives the volume of a parallelepiped.

I don't think I really understood determinants qualitatively until I used the triple scalar product in Calc 3 to find the volume of a parallelepiped.

A good introductory book (with proofs) is "Introduction to Linear Algebra" by Lang (be sure not to get his more advanced "Linear algebra"). https://www.amazon.com/dp/0387962050/?tag=pfamazon01-20
A very very good book (but also more advanced) is Treil's "Linear algebra done wrong": http://www.math.brown.edu/~treil/papers/LADW/LADW.html It is completely free too.

I second the suggestion of Lang's book. As you point out, be sure to get the intro book. I accidentally got 'Linear Algebra' instead of 'Intro to Linear Algebra' at first, and quickly got in very well over my head.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yashbhatt said:
Hello, I have been studying matrices and determinants recently and do not understand why certain things are done the way they are. Like, why is matrix multiplication defined the way it is.

I find that there are not enough proofs. Is there any book/article/video that any of you recommend to gain a better understanding of matrices and determinants?

give enough time to the problems. do not see your watch again and again. plan for atleast 1 hour a day for matrices. then after somedays interest will be build up
 
TL;DR Summary: What topics to cover to safely say I know arithmetic ? I am learning arithmetic from Indian NCERT textbook. Currently I have finished addition ,substraction of 2 digit numbers and divisions, multiplication of 1 digit numbers. I am moving pretty slowly. Can someone tell me what topics to cover first to build a framework and then go on in detail. I want to learn fast. It has taken me a year now learning arithmetic. I want to speed up. Thanks for the help in advance. (I also...
Hi community My aim is to get into research about atoms, specifically, I want to do experimental research that explores questions like: 1. Why do Gallium/Mercury have low melting points 2. Why are there so many exceptions and inconsistencies when it comes to explaining molecular structures / reaction mechanisms in inorganic and organic chemistry 3. Experimental research about fundamental Quantum Mechanics, such as the one being followed by Hiroshima university that proved that observing...
guys i am currently studying in computer science engineering [1st yr]. i was intrested in physics when i was in high school. due to some circumstances i chose computer science engineering degree. so i want to incoporate computer science engineering with physics and i came across computational physics. i am intrested studying it but i dont know where to start. can you guys reccomend me some yt channels or some free courses or some other way to learn the computational physics.
Back
Top