Having difficulty understanding radicals

MathJakob
Messages
161
Reaction score
5
I know how the very basics but then I get given a question like this.

##\sqrt{9-3x}## and I think I can divide both by 3. ##3\sqrt{3-x}## and so ##x=3##

Then I get ##\sqrt{4x+12}## and again I can take 4 from each ##4\sqrt{x+3}## and so ##x=-3##

Is this the correct way to be solving these? Because I'm looking down the page and it starts getting real complicated looking, real fast and was just wondering if there is a simple way to go about solving these?

Simplify: ##{\sqrt\frac{9a}{8b^2}}## is the next question I face
 
Last edited:
Mathematics news on Phys.org
MathJakob said:
##\sqrt{9-3x}## and I think I can divide both by 3. ##3\sqrt{3-x}##
##\sqrt{9-3x}## is not the same as ##3\sqrt{3-x}##. Consider x=0, for example, and see what you get in the different expressions.

"and so x=3" does not make sense. There is no equality involved in the expressions.

Is this the correct way to be solving these?
To solve anything, you need an equation. something=somethingelse.
Simplify: ##{\sqrt\frac{9a}{8b^2}}## is the next question I face
There are rules for square roots (more general: rules for exponents) you can use here.
 
Also here is another one but I'm not sure it's correct:

##{\sqrt\frac{8}{9}}## = ##{\sqrt\frac{8}{9}\cdot{\sqrt\frac{9}{9}}}## = ##{\sqrt\frac{72}{81}}## =## \frac{\sqrt{72}}{9}##

?
 
That is correct.
 
MathJakob said:
I know how the very basics but then I get given a question like this.

##\sqrt{9-3x}## and I think I can divide both by 3. ##3\sqrt{3-x}## and so ##x=3##

Then I get ##\sqrt{4x+12}## and again I can take 4 from each ##4\sqrt{x+3}## and so ##x=-3##

Is this the correct way to be solving these? Because I'm looking down the page and it starts getting real complicated looking, real fast and was just wondering if there is a simple way to go about solving these?

Simplify: ##{\sqrt\frac{9a}{8b^2}}## is the next question I face

The distinction between the root symbol and grouping symbols is that although both are grouping symbols, the root symbol is a function symbol. Inside the root symbol, you can factor one or more common factors from terms, but you cannot necessarily move them outside of the root symbol; because doing so requires that you have great enough count of the factors as indicated by the root index.

\sqrt{9-3x} you can do \sqrt{3(3-x)} but not further.

([strike]All I did was added the proper parentheses for grouping symbol balancing and the typesetting fails. [/strike] [strike]I NEED the paired parentheses in the second expression! [/strike] The typesetting did work but failed while I first made the post and mathematical notation.)
 
Last edited:
I really want the typesetting to work right but it did not so I do this instead:

(9-3x)1/2 is the same as (3(3-x))1/2 but you cannot go any further.
 
This is something you will commonly see/use:

##\frac{1}{2} \sqrt{x} = \sqrt{\frac{1}{4}} \; \sqrt{x} = \sqrt{\frac{x}{4}}##
##\sqrt{4x} = \sqrt{4} \; \sqrt{x} = 2 \sqrt{x}##

Also ##\sqrt{54} = \sqrt{9 * 6} = 3 \sqrt{6}##.

These are all explained by replacing each radical with the corresponding exponent, like ##(\frac{x}{4})^{\frac{1}{2}}##.
 
MathJakob said:
Also here is another one but I'm not sure it's correct:

##{\sqrt\frac{8}{9}}## = ##{\sqrt\frac{8}{9}\cdot{\sqrt\frac{9}{9}}}## = ##{\sqrt\frac{72}{81}}## =## \frac{\sqrt{72}}{9}##

?
That's true but \sqrt{9}= 3 so that \frac{\sqrt{8}}{3} would be better. In fact, since 8= 4(2) and \sqrt{8}= 2\sqrt{2}, the simplest form is \frac{2\sqrt{2}}{3}= \frac{2}{3}\sqrt{2}.
 
Back
Top