Help with 2 simple probability probs

  • Thread starter Thread starter Juntao
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Probability
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around two probability problems. The first problem involves calculating the number of different meal combinations from a restaurant's menu, where the correct approach is to consider all possible combinations of three courses rather than multiplying all options for four courses. The second problem addresses whether 250 families can have unique garage door signals with 8 buttons, leading to the conclusion that there are 255 unique combinations when excluding the case of no buttons pressed. Participants emphasize understanding the underlying principles of probability rather than rote memorization of formulas. Overall, the conversation highlights the importance of logical reasoning in solving probability problems.
Juntao
Messages
45
Reaction score
0
help with 2 "simple" probability probs

Ok, I'm having a hard time with probability.

First problem.
A restaurant offers a choice of 4 appetizers, 14 entrees, 6 desserts, and 5 beverages. How many different meals are possible if a diner intends to order only three courses? (consider the beverage to be a course)

Maybe I'm making this problem harder than it is. I want to do 4*14*6*5 = answer, but that would only be for a 4 course meal, not a three course meal...right?

Second problem

Residents of a condominium have an automatic garage opener that has a row of 8 buttons. Each garage door has been programmed to respond to a particular set of buttons being pushed. If the condominium has 250 families, can residents be assured that no two garage doors will open on the same signal? If so, how many additional families can be aded before the 8-button code becomes inadequate? *Note* The order in which the buttons are pushed is irrelevant.

I was thinking maybe the answer would be like 250^8, but that doesn't seem right to me. Since the order doesn't matter, 8 buttons such as 12345678 would be same thing as 87654321.

So I was thinking maybe answer was 8! ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
First problem: You need to consider all the ways it is possible to get 3 courses.

Second problem: A button will either be depressed or it will not. That gives two choices for each of 8 buttons. Also note that the case with no buttons pressed should be excluded.
 
1st problem:
4*14*6 + 14*6*5 + 4*14*5

2nd problem:
2^8=256
 
Actually, Tile was right, 00000000 should be excluded, so it should be
256-1=255

Simply consider it's an 8-digit binary number.
 
jxiemail said:
1st problem:
4*14*6 + 14*6*5 + 4*14*5

It's almost midnight where I'm from and I am feeling very sleepy. I can't think straight but this doesn't look right. The way I see it there are 4 ways of choosing 3 beverages from 4 beverages. So the answer is = 4*14*6*5*4.
 
n(ABC+ABD+ACD+BCD)
= n(ABC)+n(ABD)+n(ACD)+n(BCD)
=n(A)*n(B)*n(C)+n(A)*n(B)*n(D)+n(A)*n(C)*n(D)+n(B)*n(C)*n(D)

-- AI
 
TenaliRaman said:
n(ABC+ABD+ACD+BCD)
= n(ABC)+n(ABD)+n(ACD)+n(BCD)
=n(A)*n(B)*n(C)+n(A)*n(B)*n(D)+n(A)*n(C)*n(D)+n(B)*n(C)*n(D)

-- AI

That looks like a handful. :bugeye: Not entirely elegant, is it? But it is good to memorise this just in case you are not able to solve it logically in an exam.
 
No need to memorize ... it comes directly from a theorem called as the addition theorem ... its more important to understand what i did in my first step rather what i have done in the following steps ... because they are derived from the theorem itself ...

-- AI
P.S -> I put the answers in the hope that it will encourage the enquiring mind as to what and how those steps came ... instead of simply rote learning them ...
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
69K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
0
Views
22K
Replies
0
Views
17K
Replies
1
Views
25K
Replies
0
Views
21K
Replies
1
Views
28K
Back
Top