Help with understanding a floor proof

  • Thread starter Thread starter Temp0
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Proof
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on proving that if x - floor(x) < 1/2, then floor(2x) equals 2 floor(x). The proof begins by establishing that 2x is bounded by 2 floor(x) and 2 floor(x) + 1, which leads to the conclusion that floor(2x) must equal 2 floor(x). Participants clarify that both floor(x) and floor(2x) are integers, and the inequalities support this relationship. Two cases are examined based on the fractional part of x, confirming that in both scenarios, floor(2x) is either equal to or greater than 2 floor(x). The overall logic hinges on understanding the properties of floor functions and the implications of the initial inequality.
Temp0
Messages
79
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Prove that for any real number x, if x - floor(x) < 1/2, then floor(2x) = 2 floor(x)

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


Assuming that x is a real number. Suppose that x - floor(x) < 1/2
Multiplying both sides by 2, 2x < 2 floor(x) + 1
from the definition, 2 floor(x) <= 2x
2 floor(x) is an integer, and 2 floor(x) <= 2x < 2 floor(x) + 1
Implying floor(2x) = 2 floor(x)

My question is, how does the proof imply the result? I don't see how the logic works. Thank you for any help you can provide in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Temp0 said:
2 floor(x) is an integer, and 2 floor(x) <= 2x < 2 floor(x) + 1
Implying floor(2x) = 2 floor(x)

My question is, how does the proof imply the result? I don't see how the logic works. Thank you for any help you can provide in advance.

The key is that floor(x) and floor(2x) are both integers and the relation you have above is 2floor(x) < 2 floor(x) + 1. You seem to be missing the part where 2floor(x) <= floor(2x).
 
I see... I guess I missed that part, haha, just wondering, does it come from the inequality:

floor (2x) <= 2x < floor(2x) + 1 ?

I can see how it relates... kind of, since

2 floor (x) <= 2x as well, but how does

2floor(x) <= floor (2x) ?
 
2 floor(x) is always less than or equal to floor(2x).

If you let ## x = x_{int} + x_{frac} ## where ##x_{int}\in \mathbb{Z}, 0 \leq x_{frac}<1##
Then ##\text{floor}(x) = x_{int}=x-x_{frac}##
## 2\text{floor}(x) = 2x_{int}=2x-2x_{frac}##
But floor(2x) has 2 cases:
case 1:
##x_{frac}<.5 \implies 2x_{frac} < 1 \implies floor(2x) = 2 x_{int} = 2floor(x) ##
case 2:
##.5 \leq x_{frac}<1 \implies 2x_{frac} \geq 1 \implies floor(2x) = 2 x_{int} + 1=2floor(x) + 1 ##
In both cases, floor(2x) ##\geq ## 2floor(x) .
 
  • Like
Likes Greg Bernhardt

Similar threads

Back
Top