Hey. answer my qustion

  • Thread starter bilkul_king
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Hey
In summary: The messages will be received at the same rate as they were sent, but the traveler will experience a delay in his return trip. The total number of messages received by the traveler will be the sum of the number of messages sent and the number of messages received while he was on the way, minus the number of messages received while he was on the way back. In this case, the traveler will receive 30 messages in total.
  • #1
hey...please answer my qustion

can someone please solve this paradox related to the twin paradox??
jane continues to be on Earth and dick goes to a planet 20 light years away at a speed of 0.8 c. Every year dick sends a message to Jane. Now for Jane due to time dilation the time taken by dick to reach the planet is 25 years and back to Earth another 25 years. Also the frequency the Jane receive the messages while dick is receding away should be equal to one message per three years and while he is coming back it should be equal to three messages per year. Now to due to length contraction dick feels that he is twelve light year away from the planet. Hence he should take 15 years to reach the planet and 15 years back to earth. That means he has sent out a total of 30 messages. Please explain tome how Jane receives these 30 messages.


I DIDN'T GET THAT.see
1) according to dick, while he receding for the 15 years he gets five messages in total in 15 yrs @ 1 msg per 3 yr
and while coming back he is receiving 3 messages per year and for 15 yrs, he will receive 45 messages
that mean a total of 50 messages which is same as the number of messages sent out by jane in 50 yrs wrt earth.


2)
now if i perform the same calculations on jane, she should get 25*(1/3) messages from dick while he is receding and 25*3 messages while he is coming back.
but that does not amount to a total of 30 messages sent out by dean.


PLZ PLZ PLZ PERFORM THESE CALCULATIONS FOR ME HERE.

AND IN A BOOK WHERE I FOUND THE QUESTION IS FOUND IT PUT AS:--

receding 25*(1/3)

because the planet is 20 lght yrs away jane on Earth continues to receive dick's msgs @ 1/3 per year FOR TWETY more years.

PLZ EXPLAIN HOW THIS STATEMENT IS VALID...
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The calculation in #2 is not correct. Jane receives 15 messages that Dick sent while he was receding, but she does not receive all those messages while Dick is receding. He is on the way home before she receives most of them. It takes 45 years of her time to receive the first 15 messages coming to her at the rate of one every three years, and then another 5 years to receive the last 15 messges coming to her at the rate of 3 per year.
 
  • #3
space-time diagram

Drawing a space-time diagram should help improve your understanding. I drew one as a quick example...in Paint, so please excuse the crudity. The traveler is moving at v=.8c. Earth is sending one signal every year. The dotted lines represent the signals from earth, except from the line through the origin which simply represents the line x=ct, to which the others should be parallel and equidistant. The solid lines represent the traveler's path to a fixed point 4ly away from earth, and back. You can see how he will receive only one on the journey out, then the other eight on the way back. Likewise, you can draw lines for the signals being sent out by the traveler (perpendicular to his path), and visualize the rate at which the Earth receives the signals.
 

Attachments

  • std.JPG
    std.JPG
    13.6 KB · Views: 443

1. What is the purpose of "Hey. answer my question"?

The purpose of "Hey. answer my question" is to request a response or explanation to a question or inquiry.

2. How can I ensure that my question is answered?

To ensure that your question is answered, make sure it is clear, specific, and relevant. Providing context and background information can also help in receiving a thorough response.

3. Is it appropriate to use "Hey. answer my question" in a professional setting?

In a professional setting, it is best to use more formal and direct language when requesting a response or answer to a question. Phrases such as "Please provide a response to my inquiry" or "I would appreciate your input on this matter" may be more appropriate.

4. Can I use "Hey. answer my question" when asking for help or advice?

Yes, "Hey. answer my question" can be used when seeking help or advice. However, it is important to be respectful and courteous in your request and to be open to any potential responses or suggestions.

5. Is there a specific format or structure that should be used in "Hey. answer my question"?

There is no specific format or structure that must be used in "Hey. answer my question". However, it is important to be clear and concise in your request and to provide any necessary information to ensure a thorough response.

Suggested for: Hey. answer my qustion

Replies
16
Views
831
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
892
Replies
19
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
20K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Back
Top