How Can Hydrogen Be Separated from Water Safely and Efficiently?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jack001
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Hydrogen Water
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on alternative methods for separating hydrogen from water, particularly through the use of catalysts like titanium oxide under sunlight. A key point raised is the need for effective separation of hydrogen and oxygen to prevent explosive mixtures, with suggestions including the use of semi-permeable membranes and pressure swing adsorption (PSA) technology. It is noted that while hydrogen is lighter than oxygen, gases do not naturally separate based solely on density, necessitating additional methods such as size exclusion or electrical barriers. The conversation also highlights the potential of carbon nanotubes and graphene as effective hydrogen separators, although challenges with oxygen stability remain. Overall, the exploration of innovative separation techniques is crucial for advancing hydrogen production methods.
jack001
Messages
38
Reaction score
0
hello folks,

i was wondering if any other possible process of separating hydrogen from water without or less risk, any alternative method of electrolysis.

i have googled this thing and stuck to process of introducing a catalyst 'titania(titanium oxide)' in the presence of sunlight, directly converts water into the molecules of hydrogen and oxygen.
But now what? I mean how to separate this two different gases?
i suppose semi-permeable membrane can help in separation.

guide me if i am wrong.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
wont the hydrogen float above the oxygen?
 
jedishrfu said:
wont the hydrogen float above the oxygen?

I don't think you want to be mixing hydrogen and oxygen. They tend to explode when combined. Hence the need to separate them before they get out of the water.
 
^^ yes of course, they explode, so i need to separate them.
 
Take a look at PSA's.
 
so if hydrogen floats above oxygen then you could separate them by knowing where the dividing line is amd by placing valves at two distinct vertical levels to remove some gas at a time while the reaction is taking place.
 
Gasses do not separate just because one of them is 'lighter' than the other. They will mix just like two different sized ping pong balls bouncing around in a box.
 
Agreed, unless you cool the mix and separate via liquefaction.
 
but won't it explode as soon as it is converted into gas?
 
  • #10
Q_Goest said:
Take a look at PSA's.

can you please elaborate this technology.
 
  • #11
The Wiki article describes PSA pretty well- it somewhat fits into the first method below for semipermeable membrane separation, but needs a driving force to release the adsorped molecules from the pores (usually atomic dimensioned channels in Xeolites).-semi-permeable membranes rely on pores that can be used to exclude by one of several mechanisms. The most obvious one is to select by size and that H2 molecules are smaller than O2 molecules, so pores on the order of a few Angstroms can reject O2- a pressure differential exists between the two sides to drive the process.

Other methods can place an electrical or Donnan potential barrier at the pore's mouth that helps reject one type of molecule over another (mostly seen in R.O. membranes where charged dissociated salts are rejected while largely neutral H2O passes through).

Some vander Waal's forces can also create a selectivity for one type of molecule over the other, and the attractive forces used to help coax the right molecule through a pore. In this sense, the metals that are known to adsorb H2 can act as an appropriate barrier for other molecules- the downside is that these metals also recombine O2 and H2 to water catalytically, so efficiency suffers.

Thus the interest in CNT and graphenes as H2 separators; O2 stability is still a problem.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top