How do I calculate the heat sink value for this MOSFET design?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the calculation of the heat sink value for a specific MOSFET design, focusing on the mathematical determination of thermal resistance in degrees Celsius per watt (C/W). Participants seek to clarify the appropriate methodology and values needed for effective heat sink design, including ambient temperature considerations and power dissipation.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant proposes using the formula (Tmax - Tamb)/Pd to calculate the heat sink value, arriving at a result of 0.4 C/W.
  • Another participant questions the correctness of this approach, suggesting that the thermal resistances Rθ_JC and Rθ_CS from the datasheet should be considered, along with Rθ_CA for the heat sink.
  • A different participant emphasizes the need to know the actual power loss expected in the application, suggesting that the 280W figure mentioned is unrealistic for practical use.
  • One participant provides a more detailed formula for calculating the junction temperature and rearranging it to find the required thermal resistance for the heat sink.
  • Another participant mentions that effective heat sink design may require consulting existing products and their thermal ratings, particularly for natural convection and forced air scenarios.
  • One participant expresses a desire to independently calculate the heat sink requirements and acknowledges their limited background in thermodynamics.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the correct method for calculating the heat sink value. There are competing views on the appropriate approach and the assumptions regarding power dissipation and thermal resistance.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that accurate thermal resistance values depend on various factors, including the specific application, cooling methods, and the actual power losses, which remain uncertain without further calculations and real-world testing.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals involved in electronics design, particularly those working with MOSFETs and thermal management, may find this discussion relevant.

sayeen
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Hi, i want to design a heat sink for following mosfet

http://au.element14.com/vishay-formerly-i-r/irfp360pbf/mosfet-n-400v-23a-to-247ac/dp/8649359

its technical data sheet is provided here

http://www.irf.com/product-info/datasheets/data/irfp360.pdf

i am not sure how to design it...by design i mean just the mathematical value for C/W not schematic.

i read somewhere that the formula for finding the value for heat sink is (Tmax - Tamb)/Pd

the ambient temperature is 40C

from my calculation i found the heat sink value to be (150-40)/(280) = 0.4 C/W...is this correct...i located the value for Tmax and Pd (power dessipated) from the datasheet. Is this correct? please any help is appreciated.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
sayeen said:
Hi, i want to design a heat sink for following mosfet

http://au.element14.com/vishay-formerly-i-r/irfp360pbf/mosfet-n-400v-23a-to-247ac/dp/8649359

its technical data sheet is provided here

http://www.irf.com/product-info/datasheets/data/irfp360.pdf

i am not sure how to design it...by design i mean just the mathematical value for C/W not schematic.

i read somewhere that the formula for finding the value for heat sink is (Tmax - Tamb)/Pd

the ambient temperature is 40C

from my calculation i found the heat sink value to be (150-40)/(280) = 0.4 C/W...is this correct...i located the value for Tmax and Pd (power dessipated) from the datasheet. Is this correct? please any help is appreciated.

I did a Google Images search on the package and added the word heatsink, and got lots of good images. Maybe follow some of the picture links to get to websites with more information on heatsinks for that device package:

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&...source=og&sa=N&tab=wi&ei=i5Z0UKyfK8mUiAKKg4FA

.
 
Thanks, but i am looking for the ratings of the heat sink first...i want to confirm if 0.4C/W rating for the heat sink is correct.
 
sayeen said:
Thanks, but i am looking for the ratings of the heat sink first...i want to confirm if 0.4C/W rating for the heat sink is correct.

No, you are not approaching this correctly. Look at the datasheet where it lists the Rθ_JC and Rθ_CS. What do they add up to? And that doesn't include the heat sink's Rθ_CA (case to air). And you are not going to run that part at 280W, if that's what you are implying in your previous post.

What real power level are you planning on running this FET at? What is the application? Do you have forced air available to blow over the heatsink?

You should google Heatsink Tutorial, and you will get some very good hits, including ones at heatsink manufacturers and also at FEA software vendors like COMSOL. To "design" this heatsink, you can either look at what is available for that package already (and see what their values of Rθ_CA are, or you can use COMSOL or ANSYS or some other FEA software package to do the thermal simulations...
 
Hello Sayeen:

The Basic formula you are looking for is Tj = T Ambient + (Rth(total) ( Rth(j-c) + Rth(c-s) + Rth(s-a) ) * Watts Loss) Sorry hard to show in text. th-theta ... Rth thermal resistance, j=junction, c=case, s=sink, a=ambient.

So you can rearrange to get an Rth needed for the Heatsink. Your basic formula is the right idea not not complete & you come up with Rth of 0.4 Deg C/W needed. You are not including the Heatsink - so the device's rating of 0.45 C/W ( Rth(j-c)+Rth(c-s)) is really the result of your calculation.

Berkman is correct - you will NEVER get 240W loss "out of" this device - that data point is at Tcase of 25C ( a standard measurement point for comparing devices - but essentially never a real applicable rating) . However if your converter is 240W and you are 95% efficient, then you have 12W Loss Possible - so you NEED to know what you LOSSES will be in Watts.

TO make an effective heatsink will not be as easy as it seems. I would first go to Newark's website This is a TO-247 Case - and search for TO-247 and HeatSink - they have a bunch for Wakefield ( Wakefiled also has a lot of good info on their site) - for Natural Convection ( no fan) these run 3-15 C/W -- and if you notice these ratings are often expressed as Temp C @ 6W ( I take that to mean that is a typical level of heat these will see w/out a fan is in the 6W range !) With a Fan N you get a 3 to 10X improvement - depending on the design. (I know you may want to do this yourself - but a real HS at $5 or less will be very hard to beat and less than the cost of the MOSFET)

So try to estimate your Losses first - but note an accurate number will not be available until you use a REAL Heatsink Rth. Once a HS concept or ballpark is determined you will need to go back over the calculations - all of the values are interrelated ( The higher the temp the higher the losses - I always start with Tjmaz 125C ( unless a newer 175C rated device - then 150C). - I refer to this as my design limit. Estimate losses, Tambient, NAtual, Fan or Liquid cooled - pick a "typical" heatsink and look at the result. You can "add silicon" as we say reducing losses with bigger, better or more devices, or add cooling with bigger better heatsinking.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the info Berkman and Windact...Thermodynamics is not really the field of my study so i got lost there a bit...but you cleared it up..i will try to follow your advice...I will try to calculate Rth for sink by following the formula you have provided...I understand i can ask any local vendor regarding the info for the heat sink for a particular MOSFET...but I have made it a point to do it all by myself! Thanks again
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
18K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
8K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
3K