Originally posted by Artman
One of the reasons given for the variation in the calculations for the next time Mars should be as close to the Earth (approx 230 years) and the Possible last time it was so close (5000 to 60,000) was the effect not of our planet's gravitation, but the effect of Jupiter's gravitation on Mars.
No, I don't think it had anything to do with an influence from Jupiter. Phobos said it right, it was the particular conditions of Earth's and Mars' orbits.
To add a little more, for this "close" event to happen at opposition, Earth would have to be at "
Aphelion" (farthest from the sun in orbit) and Mars would have to be at "
Perihelion" (closest to the sun), or
very near these positions. But, it would seem that this would happen more often than it did since 50,000 to 60,000 years ago.
It does. However, there is one more "orbital condition" to consider that I haven't seen mentioned here on PF.
The Earth's orbit is inclined from the
ecliptic at 0.00 degrees. (This is how the ecliptic was determined, in relation to Earth only). Mars is inclined at 1.31 degrees.
So, not only do we need the Aphelion-Perihelion thing going on, but Mars would have to be at the particular point in orbit where its inclination is 0, or very near to it.
It is all three conditions that have to be met to make such a close opposition happen.
Labguy