How do we know the stars are not our own light falling back.

In summary, there are many theories about the origin of the light we see from stars and galaxies, including the possibility that it could be light from our own system falling back on its point of origin. However, this theory does not account for the specific red shifts of distant galaxies. The question has been extensively discussed with no clear answer.
  • #1
Colm
4
0
How do we know that the stars we see, or some of them are not the light from our own system falling back, and that we may be looking at light from our own star/solar system/ galaxy that has taken millions of years to fall back on its point of origin?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
Colm said:
How do we know that the stars we see, or some of them are not the light from our own system falling back, and that we may be looking at light from our own star/solar system/ galaxy that has taken millions of years to fall back on its point of origin?
Why do you think it is possible for light to "fall back"? How would this result in our seeing MILLIONS of distinct galaxies? How would it account for the specific red shifts of distant galaxies? I could go on and on but it's pointless. The answers are many-fold.
 
  • Like
Likes Colm
  • #3
We could be falling through a universe rather than moving "up and out" through it, the shell of this universe could be collapsing and the reflected points are where light is reflected from, our could be a focal point due to lensing. Light, which is also a particle, and can not escape a black hole, would first rise "up" from our point, (constantly moving) and eventually get drawn back in the same direction we are headed
 
  • #4
Of course this is probably not the case, but for the interest of the point of view, at x magnitude of gravity, in a fixed point how far could a photon travel before being bent back to its point of origin. Perhaps also to not think of it like a ball going up and down, gravity could bend that light around in a circle, so even if the point of origin moved through space, the gravity could be bending light back around and in the direction of our observation point, so would appear to be ahead of us in the direction we are traveling through the universe.. Also to explain the millions of point sources (stars and galaxies).. the light would only come back as a diffuse glow if a reflective boundary was uniform, if there was a boundary to the universal bubble that was pointed like a tesseract, the observation would be different, with light being focused at points.
 
  • #5
phinds said:
How would it account for the specific red shifts of distant galaxies? I could go on and on but it's pointless. The answers are many-fold.
Yes, and my first thought has been the line spectra of the stars we observe, or the radio emissions, or gamma emissions or, or, or. As @phinds has said: the answers are many-fold.

There is simply no way that the electromagnetic waves we receive are originated by ourselves.

The question has been answered and a further discussion makes no sense.
Thread closed.
 

1. How do we know that the light from stars is not our own light falling back?

Scientists have studied the properties of light and have determined that the light we see from stars is not our own light being reflected back to us. This is because the light from stars is much older than the light from our own Sun and has traveled through vast distances in space before reaching our eyes.

2. What evidence supports the idea that stars are not our own light falling back?

One of the main pieces of evidence is the fact that stars emit different colors of light, indicating that they are made up of different elements and have different temperatures. Additionally, the positions and movements of stars in the sky have been observed and mapped, showing that they are separate objects in space and not reflections of our own light.

3. How do we know that the light from stars is not just a mirage or illusion?

While it may seem like the stars are just twinkling lights in the sky, scientists have used advanced technology and telescopes to observe and study the properties of light coming from stars. These observations have confirmed that the light is coming from actual objects in space and not an optical illusion.

4. Can we see the same stars from different parts of the world?

Yes, we can see the same stars from different parts of the world. This is because the stars are not reflections of our own light, but rather distant objects in space that can be seen from different locations on Earth. However, the position and visibility of certain stars may vary depending on the time of year and the viewer's location on Earth.

5. Are there any other explanations for the light we see from stars?

Some people have proposed alternative theories, such as the idea that the stars are actually holes in a dome or projection of light from another source. However, these theories do not have scientific evidence to support them and go against our current understanding of the properties of light and the universe. The most widely accepted explanation for the light from stars is that it is emitted by actual objects in space.

Similar threads

Replies
6
Views
958
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
10
Views
503
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
26
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
6
Views
940
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
3
Replies
87
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
610
Back
Top