How do you derive this x^(x/8)=4x

  • Thread starter Thread starter reverend
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Derive
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the differentiation of the equation x^(x/8) = 4x. Participants clarify that while functions can be differentiated, equations themselves cannot, leading to confusion about the original intent of the problem. The correct differentiation approach involves using implicit differentiation, yielding the derivative dy/dx = (1/8 + (1/8)ln x)x^(x/8). There is debate over whether the equation should be interpreted as seeking a minimum or maximum, suggesting a possible typo in the original expression. Ultimately, the conversation emphasizes the complexities of differentiating expressions where the exponent is a function of x.
reverend
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
How do you derivate this:

x^(x/8)=4x
Can anyone help?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I don't think you can differentiate it, but I might be wrong
 
Functions have derivatives. Equations do not.
 
y = x^(x/8),
ln y = x/8 ln x

(1/y)(dy/dx) = (x/8)(1/x) + (1/8)ln x
(dy/dx) = y(1/8 + (1/8)ln x)
dy/dx = (1/8 + (1/8)ln x)x^(x/8)

Im not sure if this is allowed. Certainly the power rule isn't allowed (eg. to say d/dx x^x = x*x^(x-1)) because the power is a function of x. But I am not sure if you can differentiate implicitly like this either...
 
I think you misread the original post. But for the problem you gave, it looks good to me.
 
Theres only one variable in your equation. What do you want to differentiate and with respect to what?
 
A derivative is a rate of change. A relative "growth" to something. You cannot possibly differentiate this, as there is only one variable, if you wish to see it that way. You COULD differentiate it with respect to itself, but i think you will find that that will not take long. I think there is an error in the problem.
 
x^(x/8)=4x means as far as I can tell a y=X^(x/8)-4x so he's probably looknig for a min or a max of it? It's poorly expressed to say the least.
 
Robokapp said:
x^(x/8)=4x means as far as I can tell a y=X^(x/8)-4x so he's probably looknig for a min or a max of it? It's poorly expressed to say the least.

But there is no y variable. You could imply it to mean y=4x-x^(x/8) as well
 
  • #10
Robokapp said:
x^(x/8)=4x means as far as I can tell a y=X^(x/8)-4x so he's probably looknig for a min or a max of it? It's poorly expressed to say the least.
I certainly wouln't assume that. I would assume the original post was asking how to differentiate both sides of the equation.
MichaelW24 already did the hard part: if you let y= x^(x/8) then
y'= (1/8 + (1/8)ln x)x^(x/8).
That's the left side of the equation. Differentiating both sides of the equation x^(x/8)=4x gives simply (1/8 + (1/8)ln x)x^(x/8)= 4.
IF "=" was a typo for "-" then the derivative of x^(x/8)- 4x is
(1/8 + (1/8)ln x)x^(x/8)- 4.
 
  • #11
By the way, if you have to differentiate
y= f(x)^{g(x)}
There are two mistakes you might make:
1. Treat the "g(x)" as if it were a constant and use the power law
y'= (g(x))f(x)^{g(x)-1}f'(x)
2. Treat the "f(x)" as if it were a constant and use the exponential law
y'= ln(f(x))f(x)^{g(x)}g'(x)

Of course, the correct answer is the sum of those:
y'= (g(x))f(x)^{g(x)-1}f'(x)+ ln(f(x))f(x)^{g(x)}g'(x)!
 
Back
Top