Medical How does thinking create action potentials?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on how the brain initiates action potentials for voluntary movements, such as picking up a pen. It begins with the recognition of a need, which triggers activity in the frontal lobe, leading to decision-making. The conversation touches on the interplay between sensory input and motor response, questioning whether decisions are purely voluntary or influenced by stimuli. A notable example is provided involving a patient with a severed corpus callosum, illustrating how the brain can fabricate explanations for actions that are not consciously processed. Ultimately, the consensus leans towards the idea that all brain activity, including decisions, is influenced by prior states and sensory information, challenging the concept of free will in the context of neuroscience.
sameeralord
Messages
659
Reaction score
3
Hello guys,

I don't know much about brain and stuff I only know a bit about action potential. My question is I can understand how sensory nerves by a stimulus, but let's say I want to pick a pen. How does brain initiate the action potential for that? This might have been dicussed before but I'm not sure what to type in google to find the answer. Thanks :smile:
 
Biology news on Phys.org
sameeralord said:
Hello guys,

I don't know much about brain and stuff I only know a bit about action potential. My question is I can understand how sensory nerves by a stimulus, but let's say I want to pick a pen. How does brain initiate the action potential for that? This might have been dicussed before but I'm not sure what to type in google to find the answer. Thanks :smile:

You first recognize the need for an implement to write with... a decision must be made, which causes diffuse activity, but especially in the frontal lobe. You're still reacting to stimulus, at whatever remove.

If you remove all external stimulus from a person, their mind will begin to create "phantoms" to fill the void. In the proper context, this is often an aspect of torture, although great care is taken because it is too easy to induce serious panic or even dissociation or dissociative fugue. That of course, makes information gleaned worthless.

Now, if you enter a sensory deprivation 'tank', and you know you can leave it at any time.. some people find that same experience relaxing. Inevitably however, our brains provide stimulus in the absence of any external source. We are ALWAYS 'on'.
 
sameeralord said:
Hello guys,

I don't know much about brain and stuff I only know a bit about action potential. My question is I can understand how sensory nerves by a stimulus, but let's say I want to pick a pen. How does brain initiate the action potential for that? This might have been dicussed before but I'm not sure what to type in google to find the answer. Thanks :smile:
How can you be sure the decision to pick up the pen isn't a response to a stimulus?
 
Pythagorean said:
How can you be sure the decision to pick up the pen isn't a response to a stimulus?

Of course, you can't be.

Nature 2009 said:
...He cites the
example of a patient whose corpus callosum
had been severed as a treatment for epilepsy,
making it impossible for one side of the brain
to communicate with the other. Gazzaniga and
his colleagues presented the word ‘walk’ to the
patient’s left visual field, which corresponds to
the right side of the brain. When the patient
stood up and began walking, they asked him
why; the right side of the patient’s brain had
been shown to lack the ability to process language.
His left brain, which never received the
walk command, but which handles language
processing, quickly invented a logical explanation:
“I wanted to go get a Coke.”
Analogous effects have been found

http://hd.media.mit.edu/01.29.09_naturemag_secsig.pdf <-- Above quote.

Really, there you have it.
 
You decide to pick up a pen through various cascade pathways, you gather sensory information via afferent neurons, see pen, then your brain will send signals to your motor neurons, causing you to pick up the pen. Very very brief explanation, if you want more detail check out: http://wps.aw.com/bc_marieb_ehap_8/25/6527/1670985.cw/index.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
sameeralord said:
Hello guys,

I don't know much about brain and stuff I only know a bit about action potential. My question is I can understand how sensory nerves by a stimulus, but let's say I want to pick a pen. How does brain initiate the action potential for that? This might have been dicussed before but I'm not sure what to type in google to find the answer. Thanks :smile:

What you are asking, I think, is how a purely volitional act originates in the brain; not as a direct response to some immediate or recent stimulus coming from the sensory input. This might be called "free will"; the idea that you can just decide to do something that is not effectively predetermined in some way. You'll find a lot of discussions about that, but no good answers. The fact is, no one knows. Neuroscientists however generally take the view that brain states are fully dependent on prior brain states (which take into account all sensory input) and there really is no such thing as 'free will'.
 
Last edited:
Chagas disease, long considered only a threat abroad, is established in California and the Southern U.S. According to articles in the Los Angeles Times, "Chagas disease, long considered only a threat abroad, is established in California and the Southern U.S.", and "Kissing bugs bring deadly disease to California". LA Times requires a subscription. Related article -...
I am reading Nicholas Wade's book A Troublesome Inheritance. Please let's not make this thread a critique about the merits or demerits of the book. This thread is my attempt to understanding the evidence that Natural Selection in the human genome was recent and regional. On Page 103 of A Troublesome Inheritance, Wade writes the following: "The regional nature of selection was first made evident in a genomewide scan undertaken by Jonathan Pritchard, a population geneticist at the...
I use ethanol for cleaning glassware and resin 3D prints. The glassware is sometimes used for food. If possible, I'd prefer to only keep one grade of ethanol on hand. I've made sugar mash, but that is hardly the least expensive feedstock for ethanol. I had given some thought to using wheat flour, and for this I would need a source for amylase enzyme (relevant data, but not the core question). I am now considering animal feed that I have access to for 20 cents per pound. This is a...
Back
Top