How Is Extra Energy Calculated in a Stretched Wire?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tulatalu
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Energy Wire
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the extra energy stored in a stretched wire when tension is increased. The initial attempt at a solution using the formula E=1/2 Fe is questioned, as it does not yield a correct answer among the provided options. The correct formula for the extra energy is identified as 1/2(T'+T)(n-m), which represents the average force times the extension. Participants emphasize the importance of understanding the relationship between energy and work, suggesting that the energy difference should equal the average work done by the tension force. The conversation concludes with a recommendation to use the formula 1/2 kx^2 for clarity in calculations.
Tulatalu
Messages
29
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


Under tension T the wire has lenghth of m, its length becomes n when the tension is increase to T'. What is the extra energy stored in the wire as a result of this process?

Homework Equations


E=1/2 Fe[/B]

The Attempt at a Solution


Extra energy= E(n)-E(m) = 1/2 x (T'n-Tm)

There is no such answer in the multiple choices. Am I wrong when I subtracted the two energy?[/B]
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I might be wrong but is that the right equation for the energy stored in a "spring"?


 
CWatters said:
I might be wrong but is that the right equation for the energy stored in a "spring"?
It is applicable to any specimens when they are extended or compressed within their limits.
 
E=1/2 Fe looks like some average force times extension when starting at zero force. $$\int_n^m T\; ds$$ would be a lot better. See what that gives. (What are the multiple choice options to choose from ?)
 
I don't think they require the exact energy. The right answer is 1/2(T'+T)(n-m) but I have no idea why.
 
Well, that IS average force times extension
 
But I just don't understand why i was wrong. Could you please explain how they get the result physically?
 
Anybody explain the result for me please ?
 
Tulatalu said:
1/2(T'+T)(n-m)

If I'm not mistaken ,, I think this is related a work-energy theorem
the energy is equal to the external work

So
$$E_f-E_i = 0.5 (T'_n-T_m)(n-m)$$

the left side is the energy difference , the right side is the average work done by the tension force [average force times the distance]
this is what i can say ,,
:)
 
  • #10
Tulatalu said:
Extra energy= E(n)-E(m) = 1/2 x (T'n-Tm)

I think that is not the right answer ,,

the left side is an energy , while the right side is a force ,,,

Check the units of each side ,,,

Are they equal ??
 
  • #11
the left side is an energy , while the right side is a force
I thought the same thought at first, until I realized it (the n and the m) was a multiplication, not a subscript.

The formula stems from inserting T = k x and ds = dx in $$\int_0^n T\; ds = \int_0^n kx\; dx = \left [{1\over 2} k x^2 \right ]^n_0 = {1\over 2} kx\; x = {1\over 2} Tx$$

(I strongly prefer and recommend ## {1\over 2} kx^2 ## !)

Numerically there isn't much difference between the 'absent' and the 'right' multiple choice

[edit] the integral bounds look a bit stupid. lower bound is equilibrium position (T=0)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top