How proportional action is produced in a pneumatic controller

5 replies · 3K views · last reply
David Deal
Messages
5
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


(a) With the aid of a sketch explain how proportional action is produced
in a pneumatic controller whose output is 0.2 to 1.0 bar. Assume that
the controller is direct acting.

(b) Show, mathematically, that the output is dependent on the difference
between the measured and desired values.

(c) With the aid of a well annotated sketch describe the construction and
operation of a P + I + D controller having a pneumatic output.

Homework Equations


none that I can think of

The Attempt at a Solution


(a) I believe I have to produce this as the first part of the question. As my lessons are pretty poor this is all I can gather from the content.
Schematic of a pneumatic proportional controller with a pivoted beam, matched pairs of bellows for desired and measured value pressures, a nozzle, integral and feedback bellows, a restrictor, and air supply and output lines.


(b) There is nothing that I can see in my notes for this. The tutor is as helpful as the notes also.

(c) I think this is what they are after, but again my lessons don't shed much light on this.
Schematic of a pneumatic proportional controller: a horizontal pivoted beam with a proportioning spring at the right end, matched bellows labelled desired value pressure and measured value pressure, a nozzle and restrictor on the air supply line, and output of 0.2-1.0 bar (3-15 p.s.i.).


I just need pointed in the right direction and I should be good to be honest.
 
Attachments
  • Schematic of a pneumatic proportional controller with a pivoted beam, matched pairs of bellows for desired and measured value pressures, a nozzle, integral and feedback bellows, a restrictor, and air supply and output lines.
    upload_2019-3-8_13-53-0.png
    14.2 KB · Views: 1,078
  • Schematic of a pneumatic proportional controller: a horizontal pivoted beam with a proportioning spring at the right end, matched bellows labelled desired value pressure and measured value pressure, a nozzle and restrictor on the air supply line, and output of 0.2-1.0 bar (3-15 p.s.i.).
    upload_2019-3-8_14-37-55.png
    13.9 KB · Views: 1,005
Try about page 17 here

http://www.instrumentationrepair.com/Documents/Manuals/Bailey/Instruments/P92-1-1.pdf

i'd download and print a copy because it takes some mental gymnastics to wrap your brain around that mechanical marvel.
The Bailey AD is a general purpose analog computer with two balance beams instead of just one as you have drawn,
but the principles of force balance and displacement balance are your basic thought tools.
 
jim hardy said:
Try about page 17 here

http://www.instrumentationrepair.com/Documents/Manuals/Bailey/Instruments/P92-1-1.pdf

i'd download and print a copy because it takes some mental gymnastics to wrap your brain around that mechanical marvel.
The Bailey AD is a general purpose analog computer with two balance beams instead of just one as you have drawn,
but the principles of force balance and displacement balance are your basic thought tools.

Thats great. Thanks for the information.

Now I have to derive an equation for Po relating to measure and desired pressures for b).
Any pointers?
 
David Deal said:
Now I have to derive an equation for Po relating to measure and desired pressures for b).
Any pointers?
well as i said force balance and displacement balance are your thought tools.

Consider forces F acting on the beam, and their distances from the pivot..

Schematic of a pneumatic proportional controller: a beam pivoted in the middle with matched bellows at each end, a nozzle under the right side, a proportioning spring above, and an air supply with restrictor.

assume all bellows have same area.
Equilibrium is when beam is balanced exactly horizontal, as shown
consider that a minute displacement from there, less than 0.001" changes nozzle pressure hence output pressure from minimum to maximum.
and for analysis imagine it takes zero movement from equilibrium to change output pressure over full range
so the nozzle is your "null" analogous to summing junction of an operational amplifier circuit.

In my opinion the spring on right end is mis-named it should be called Bias rather than Proportioning.

Since all bellows have same area, force exerted by any of them is proportional to pressure and we don't have to write area into the force balance equations.
Force up on left end of beam equals (Pmeasured - Pdesired),
and force up on right end of beam equals (Poutput - Fbias spring)

The beam is in equilibrium when sum of torques is zero
(Pmeasured - Pdesired) X D1 = (Poutput - Fbias spring) X D2
Solve for Poutput.
(You might want to set Fbias spring = 0 for starters.)

That should give you the idea what they're up to in the "How It Operates" chapter of that Bailey instruction leaflet.

It's the mechanical analogue to an operational amplifier circuit.
D1 and D2 are analogous to input and feedback resistors
and that 0.001" displacement i mentioned is analogous to open loop gain.
The AD relay has a pressure booster with gain around 20 placed between nozzle and output to increase its "open loop gain" .ie reducing the mechanical displacement necessary to achieve full output pressure swing..

Learn this stuff .
Maintaining a null has been the basis of automatic controls since well before computers.

old jm
 
Attachments
  • Schematic of a pneumatic proportional controller: a beam pivoted in the middle with matched bellows at each end, a nozzle under the right side, a proportioning spring above, and an air supply with restrictor.
    upload_2019-3-10_16-9-26.png
    13.9 KB · Views: 826
jim hardy said:
Answer to C is in that Bailey manual.

Hey Jim

Thanks for the info, someone at work is very good at PID controllers also. The above solutions are correct.

I will mark this as solved now.

Thanks again
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jim hardy