How taboo is doing undergrad and grad school at the same place?

[Frzn]

Just wondering if it people would ever go so far as NOT doing undergraduate at a school doing research they're interested in because they would want to attend grad school there

 

[Vasara]

It doesn't really matter that much, but in general it is better to see how things are done in other places and get some connections. I don't consider it taboo at all, there are plenty of people that do both degrees in the same institution. It is strongly encouraged to go to a different place for grad school though.

 

[eri]

I've heard people say they did that, but frankly I changed my specific research field about 5 times between the beginning of undergrad and the end of grad school, so it doesn't really make sense to do that (and those 5 fields were all still in astrophysics, but not really related). Unless there's a very good reason for you to stay (it's a very top school in the field or you want to work with someone very specific) it's best to move on. Schools will encourage you to go elsewhere.

 

[twofish-quant]

Just wondering if it people would ever go so far as NOT doing undergraduate at a school doing research they're interested in because they would want to attend grad school there

If you are an undergraduate then the odds are that you probably aren't familiar enough with the people in the fields involved to really know what graduate school you want to go to. You may think you do, but you probably really don't.

Selecting graduate schools is a totally different process from selecting undergraduate schools.

 

[rezeew]

I understand the importance of expanding one's academic and research experience beyond a single institution. However, I also recognize that there are advantages to completing both undergraduate and graduate studies at the same place.

On one hand, attending different institutions for undergraduate and graduate studies can provide a broader perspective and exposure to different research methodologies and approaches. It can also open up opportunities for networking and collaboration with individuals from diverse backgrounds.

On the other hand, there are benefits to staying at the same institution for both undergraduate and graduate studies. For example, students may have already established relationships with faculty members and have a better understanding of the research opportunities and resources available at the institution. This can lead to a smoother transition into graduate studies and potentially a more successful research experience.

In terms of taboo, I do not think there is a clear consensus on whether it is considered taboo to do both undergraduate and graduate studies at the same place. It ultimately depends on personal preferences and individual circumstances. Some may see it as limiting one's experience, while others may view it as a strategic decision.

However, I would caution against choosing a graduate program solely based on the institution where one completed their undergraduate studies. It is important to carefully consider the research interests, faculty expertise, and overall fit of the graduate program, regardless of whether it is at the same institution as one's undergraduate studies or not.

In conclusion, while there are pros and cons to completing both undergraduate and graduate studies at the same place, it ultimately comes down to personal choice and individual circumstances. It is important to carefully weigh the benefits and drawbacks and make an informed decision that aligns with one's academic and career goals.