- #1

- 104

- 0

But for an observer on earth the toy ship isn't moving at a constant velocity, it is accelerating. What will be the rate of acceleration of the toy ship for him?

- Thread starter Trojan666ru
- Start date

- #1

- 104

- 0

But for an observer on earth the toy ship isn't moving at a constant velocity, it is accelerating. What will be the rate of acceleration of the toy ship for him?

- #2

UltrafastPED

Science Advisor

Gold Member

- 1,912

- 216

Since the first ship has a constant acceleration of 9 m/s^2, and started from rest at the launch site we can obtain v_1(t) = 0.5 x 9 t^2 (Galileo's formula) = 4.5 t^2.

Since v_2 was given as 1 m/s we can now say that the velocity of the second ship, the toy, is

V_toy = 1 + 4.5 t^2 [m/s], where t is the time when the toy ship was launched.

The toy ship is _not_ accelerating after it has been launched - you only specified that the first ship was accelerating - presumably due to the firing of its rockets, which the toy ship lacks.

- #3

A.T.

Science Advisor

- 11,058

- 2,515

Same as the big ship.

But for an observer on earth the toy ship isn't moving at a constant velocity, it is accelerating. What will be the rate of acceleration of the toy ship for him?

- #4

- 104

- 0

- #5

A.T.

Science Advisor

- 11,058

- 2,515

No. It will be moving faster, but accelerating at the same rate.

- #6

- 104

- 0

- #7

- 104

- 0

what if the toy ship was moving with a greater velocity about 10m/s ?

If both wet accelerating at same rate then the relative velocity between the two ships must be 0

- #8

A.T.

Science Advisor

- 11,058

- 2,515

Yes.

- #9

A.T.

Science Advisor

- 11,058

- 2,515

No. Same acceleration does not imply same velocity.

what if the toy ship was moving with a greater velocity about 10m/s ?

If both wet accelerating at same rate then the relative velocity between the two ships must be 0

- #10

UltrafastPED

Science Advisor

Gold Member

- 1,912

- 216

From the conditions which you have given the toy ship is _not_ accelerating after it has been launched. You said that the "rocket ship" is accelerating at 9 m/s^2 ... this means that it is the rocket which is providing its acceleration.Suppose I'm in a rocked ship and its accelerating away from earth at a speed of 9m/s^2. From inside my rocket i start another toy rocket which moves in a uniform velocity from my reference frame at 1m/s in the direction of motion of my ship (Please note the direction of motion of both ship is same)

Thus the toy ship is being accelerated at the same rate as the rocket ship up until it is launched: after that it sees no acceleration. Please look at the calculations which I provided - they fit the conditions which you stated exactly, and provide a complete answer.

- #11

A.T.

Science Advisor

- 11,058

- 2,515

Just to clarify:From the conditions which you have given the toy ship is _not_ accelerating after it has been launched. You said that the "rocket ship" is accelerating at 9 m/s^2 ... this means that it is the rocket which is providing its acceleration.

Thus the toy ship is being accelerated at the same rate as the rocket ship up until it is launched: after that it sees no acceleration. Please look at the calculations which I provided - they fit the conditions which you stated exactly, and provide a complete answer.

Thats not how I interpret the OP. My answers assume constant velocity of small rocket, relative to big rocket after launch.

- #12

UltrafastPED

Science Advisor

Gold Member

- 1,912

- 216

Plus the OP has a lot of confused statements ... lets request that he clarify.

If the toy does have its own rocket, and accelerates at 9 m/s^2 then its velocity will be 1 m/s greater than the big rocket due to its initial velocity of 1 m/s. In that case both ships would have the same acceleration, but would have different velocities.

- #13

Khashishi

Science Advisor

- 2,815

- 493

Trojan, are you looking for a relativistically correct formula? AT's answer is correct for nonrelativistic velocities. For relativistic velocities, I believe the *coordinate acceleration* of the toy rocket (using Earth coordinates) must be less, especially if the toy rocket is traveling near c in the Earth frame. The *proper acceleration* is the same for both rockets.

If your big rocket has constant 9 m/s^2 proper acceleration, the acceleration as viewed by Earth will be decreasing in time as your rocket gets closer to c.

The number you gave, 1 m/s, is very nonrelativistic, so just use AT's answer.

If your big rocket has constant 9 m/s^2 proper acceleration, the acceleration as viewed by Earth will be decreasing in time as your rocket gets closer to c.

The number you gave, 1 m/s, is very nonrelativistic, so just use AT's answer.

Last edited:

- #14

nasu

Gold Member

- 3,772

- 429

It does not say anything about "launching".But that is inconsistent with "toy launched at 1 m/s" vs the big ship has rockets.

It says: "another toy rocket which moves in a uniform velocity from my reference frame"

Which is compatible with A.T.'s interpretation.

Uniform velocity refers to the duration of the motion and not to an instant (like the launching time).

- #15

- 104

- 0

we are not moving any closer to c, that will be complicated.

Just for last time I'm asking it again

Ill call the Big ship in which I'm sitting as "A" and the toy ship as "B"

Now just imagine everything from the observer on earth’s frame of reference. The observer on earth sees the rocket "A" moving at an acceleration of 9m/s2, after some time (I'm not giving any importance to a specific time ) the toy ship that is "B" launched with a constant velocity wrt to the A ship. So the observer on ground sees the toy ship "B" moving away from the big ship "A", am i right?

Well "MOVING AWAY" WHICH MEANS IT HAS GREATER SPEED THAN THAT OF BIG ROCKET"

Then how can the observer on Ground say the toy ship is in a constant velocity? or same acceleration as 9m/s2?

Because it was already accelerating along with the big ship, now it got additional thrust so it will be moving faster than big rocket, am i right?

Just for last time I'm asking it again

Ill call the Big ship in which I'm sitting as "A" and the toy ship as "B"

Now just imagine everything from the observer on earth’s frame of reference. The observer on earth sees the rocket "A" moving at an acceleration of 9m/s2, after some time (I'm not giving any importance to a specific time ) the toy ship that is "B" launched with a constant velocity wrt to the A ship. So the observer on ground sees the toy ship "B" moving away from the big ship "A", am i right?

Well "MOVING AWAY" WHICH MEANS IT HAS GREATER SPEED THAN THAT OF BIG ROCKET"

Then how can the observer on Ground say the toy ship is in a constant velocity? or same acceleration as 9m/s2?

Because it was already accelerating along with the big ship, now it got additional thrust so it will be moving faster than big rocket, am i right?

Last edited:

- #16

A.T.

Science Advisor

- 11,058

- 2,515

During the launch, when the toy gets that 1m/s extra speed, it has temporally a higher acceleration than the big ship. But once it moves at constant speed relative to the big ship, it has the same acceleration as the big ship in any frame (ignoring relativity).

Last edited:

- Last Post

- Replies
- 2

- Views
- 2K

- Replies
- 4

- Views
- 1K

- Last Post

- Replies
- 35

- Views
- 2K

- Last Post

- Replies
- 12

- Views
- 4K

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 675

- Last Post

- Replies
- 3

- Views
- 635

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 1K

- Replies
- 0

- Views
- 1K

- Replies
- 5

- Views
- 2K

- Replies
- 14

- Views
- 8K