How to Prove Blood Is Red

  • #1

Main Question or Discussion Point

My brother is under the misconception that blood is blue.

I'm not that good with explaining things, but so far I have convinced my dad that blood is red. My brother just does not believe that blood is red and not blue.

What are some facts to disprove the misconception that blood is blue?

I am in 9th Grade taking AP Bio and my brother is in 10th grade taking Bio, so please keep it as simple as you can. Or I can just simplify it for him 'cause he won't understand anything I will say. Also the fact that he thinks just because he's older, it means he's smarter.

So what are some explanations?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
37
2
My brother is under the misconception that blood is blue.

I'm not that good with explaining things, but so far I have convinced my dad that blood is red. My brother just does not believe that blood is red and not blue.

What are some facts to disprove the misconception that blood is blue?

I am in 9th Grade taking AP Bio and my brother is in 10th grade taking Bio, so please keep it as simple as you can. Or I can just simplify it for him 'cause he won't understand anything I will say. Also the fact that he thinks just because he's older, it means he's smarter.

So what are some explanations?
Show him so blood and ask him why it's red. When he says whatever reason he thinks it turns red then ask him HOW that occured. It'll show he doesn't actually understand. Hemoglobin can not be blue, it's just not possible you would have to take the Fe2+ ion out and put something in it's place to make it blue.

Anyways a simple way to 'prove' that blood is red is to take your brother to a blood donor clinic. Get him to donate some blood and you'll notice, the blood is a dark red possible looking sorta brownish. This blood is veinous, aka not oxygenated, blood. The blood doesn't contact oxygen during it's trip into the bag. If you do this you'll accomplish two things, you'll be correcting your elder brothers misconception on the colour of blood and you will be getting him to do a good thing in the process by donating blood :smile:
 
  • #3
Show him so blood and ask him why it's red. When he says whatever reason he thinks it turns red then ask him HOW that occured. It'll show he doesn't actually understand. Hemoglobin can not be blue, it's just not possible you would have to take the Fe2+ ion out and put something in it's place to make it blue.

Anyways a simple way to 'prove' that blood is red is to take your brother to a blood donor clinic. Get him to donate some blood and you'll notice, the blood is a dark red possible looking sorta brownish. This blood is veinous, aka not oxygenated, blood. The blood doesn't contact oxygen during it's trip into the bag. If you do this you'll accomplish two things, you'll be correcting your elder brothers misconception on the colour of blood and you will be getting him to do a good thing in the process by donating blood :smile:
Ah yes. I told him that hemoglobin cannot be red before, but could not explain how I know. I knew it was not possible, but was not sure why not either. Thanks for helping me [and my brother] out.
 
  • #4
Andy Resnick
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
Insights Author
7,428
1,921
  • #5
Matterwave
Science Advisor
Gold Member
3,965
326
Good thing we can safely assume his brother is not a horseshoe crab, or a plant...:rofl:
 
  • #6
Borek
Mentor
28,412
2,814
Good thing we can safely assume his brother is not a horseshoe crab, or a plant...:rofl:
Honestly, if he thinks blood is blue against life experience (I don't believe he never cut himself) assumption that he is neither plant nor crab doesn't seem so obvious.
 
  • #7
Pengwuino
Gold Member
4,989
15
I'm pretty confused here. Has he never cut himself before?

or does he want a WHY?
 
  • #8
CRGreathouse
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2,820
0
Honestly, if he thinks blood is blue against life experience (I don't believe he never cut himself) assumption that he is neither plant nor crab doesn't seem so obvious.
I'm pretty confused here. Has he never cut himself before?
I'm sure the brother is talking about deoxygenated blood. It's a popular misconception, actually -- helped by the appearance of veins through the skin, I think. (Also perhaps helped by the expression "blue-blooded"?)
 
  • #9
drizzle
Gold Member
366
57
He’s just misled by the veins color beneath his skin, as CRGreathouse have said... The only safe proof is to pin him with a needle! I assure you he'll never forget that :biggrin:
 
Last edited:
  • #10
For your brother,you may take him where someone are killing the pig or duck and so on.Then he can see the blood is red himself
 
  • #11
rhody
Gold Member
630
3
My brother is under the misconception that blood is blue.
First, an obvious question, does your brother have an undiagnosed color blindness ?

Rhody...
 
  • #13
DaveC426913
Gold Member
18,722
2,208
I have a feeling his conception is that deoxygenated blood is blue, but that the moment you prick yourself, it becomes immediately oxygenated and turns red.

The only way he will be convinced the blood is not blue is to show him veinous blood that has not been exposed to oxygen.


Also, I have the feeling that, given the fact that he is your older brother, he is simply yanking your chain in a lifelong effort to drive you crazy.
 
  • #14
8
0
I have a feeling his conception is that deoxygenated blood is blue, but that the moment you prick yourself, it becomes immediately oxygenated and turns red.

The only way he will be convinced the blood is not blue is to show him veinous blood that has not been exposed to oxygen.
Thats what i thought too!
Thanks for the confirmation
 
  • #15
37
2
Just to pick a nit, that's not true: replace the iron with copper, and blood is blue (Horseshoe crabs), and replace the iron with Mg and you have Chlorophyll.
Neither of those are hemoglobin and they are quite different if you study them. Just because it's part of another organisms blood does not mean it's hemoglobin.

Anyways I had mentioned in my post that you could change the colour of blood with:

you would have to take the Fe2+ ion out and put something in it's place to make it blue.
Besides the Cu+2 ion may not even be blue in humans as it's colour changes quite a bit in various pH levels. It may turn out more greenish...
 
  • #16
575
47
That's a popular myth that people still believe.
The myth is: "Blood is blue in your body until it touches the oxygen in the air and turns red. That's why you can't ever see it blue, because it turns red immediately when it hits the oxygen."

The stupid idiots ignore the fact that your blood has oxygen in it already while it's still in your body.
 
  • #17
Borek
Mentor
28,412
2,814
So teh simplest way is to draw some blood into the syringe - it avoids contact with the air this way.
 
  • #18
37
2
So teh simplest way is to draw some blood into the syringe - it avoids contact with the air this way.
Not true, because hardly any grade 10 would know if they were seeing veinous or oxygenated blood. As well it could be dangerous... I think my suggestion of going to a blood bank would be the best, that way it's safe and you it's a sure thing that what you see being extracted is veinous blood that has not been oxygenated. It's also a sure thing that it never contacted any air during the trip.
 
  • #19
Borek
Mentor
28,412
2,814
Not true, because hardly any grade 10 would know if they were seeing veinous or oxygenated blood.
Both are red. They differ in shade, but neither is blue.

And I was not proposing to draw you own blood, that was rather general idea how to approach the problem.
 
  • #20
37
2
Both are red. They differ in shade, but neither is blue.
Yes, I know they are both red, however the problem is that the misconception is that veinous blood is blue (deoxygenated) and turns red upon receiving oxygen. Your suggestion is good but I think the OP was looking for a more realistic solution which he could use to show that the misconception is false. If they had drawn blood using a syringe they wouldn't be able to tell the difference (more than likely) and may even have a mixed sample of veinous and arterial blood which compromises the results.
 
  • #21
My bro thinks that deoxygenated blood is blue, just to clear things up.
I told him about the hemoglobin, but I think it just went over his head. And when I told him about the 'drawing blood from veins' thing and he decided to ask me how it's possible for the syringe to be clear of oxygen. He's not a science guy, so when I talk about something that involves some degree of science, it goes right over his head.

He was brought under the misconception by his biology teacher and his biology teacher learned it from her professor in college(I think my brother/his teacher made up the professor thing, but maybe my brother misunderstood what his teacher was saying. He tends to not pay full attention sometimes)
 
  • #22
37
2
My bro thinks that deoxygenated blood is blue, just to clear things up.
I told him about the hemoglobin, but I think it just went over his head. And when I told him about the 'drawing blood from veins' thing and he decided to ask me how it's possible for the syringe to be clear of oxygen. He's not a science guy, so when I talk about something that involves some degree of science, it goes right over his head.

He was brought under the misconception by his biology teacher and his biology teacher learned it from her professor in college(I think my brother/his teacher made up the professor thing, but maybe my brother misunderstood what his teacher was saying. He tends to not pay full attention sometimes)
Well if he doesn't believe that when blood is drawn there isn't oxygen in the bag or tube etc. then... just a lost cause. There's absolutely no way to prove to him that human blood is red. He doesn't understand the chemistry and he doesn't 'believe' the proof. So basically he just believes it 'just because' without having any evidence to support the position.

It's entirely plausible though that he's just yanking your chain though... that tends to happen a lot in brotherly love relationships :wink:.
 
  • #23
Well if he doesn't believe that when blood is drawn there isn't oxygen in the bag or tube etc. then... just a lost cause. There's absolutely no way to prove to him that human blood is red. He doesn't understand the chemistry and he doesn't 'believe' the proof. So basically he just believes it 'just because' without having any evidence to support the position.

It's entirely plausible though that he's just yanking your chain though... that tends to happen a lot in brotherly love relationships :wink:.
Nah, I can tell he's not messing with me. But as you said, he does not understand the chemistry nor does he believe the proofs. I already proved to him why it's red through 3 explanations, but he's not accepting it, I guess.
 
  • #24
575
47
Nah, I can tell he's not messing with me. But as you said, he does not understand the chemistry nor does he believe the proofs. I already proved to him why it's red through 3 explanations, but he's not accepting it, I guess.
Some people get stuck with one idea because they want it to be true.
For example, someone can find some false information online and automatically believe it, yet no amount of further online information debunking that false claim will ever convince them.
 
  • #25
DaveC426913
Gold Member
18,722
2,208
...when I told him about the 'drawing blood from veins' thing and he decided to ask me how it's possible for the syringe to be clear of oxygen....
Does he realize that the very functioning of a syringe requires that it not have anything in it at all? That's how it draws blood out. Pulling back on the plunger draws blood into the vacuum.
 

Related Threads on How to Prove Blood Is Red

Replies
3
Views
15K
Replies
1
Views
6K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
7K
Replies
6
Views
23K
Replies
6
Views
70K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
5K
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
2K
Top