How were Hiroshima and Nagasiki bombs filmed? Did the pilots survive?

  • Thread starter Thread starter tsuwal
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the safety of the aircraft crew involved in the Hiroshima bombing and the accuracy of historical representations of the event. It is confirmed that the pilots and crew were not adversely affected by the bomb, as they maintained a safe distance during the drop and were instructed to maneuver to avoid the blast's effects. A second plane accompanied the mission to capture photographs, but it only succeeded in obtaining one iconic image of the explosion. Concerns are raised about the historical accuracy of documentaries that mix footage from different bombings, which can mislead viewers regarding the events of Hiroshima. The discussion also references a military channel show that inaccurately depicted the type of bomb used, highlighting the importance of accurate historical representation.
tsuwal
Messages
105
Reaction score
0
The bomb kills everything around it so i was wondering if the people who shot the bomb where safe or even if the pilots health was affected by the bomb..
 
Physics news on Phys.org
tsuwal said:
The bomb kills everything around it so i was wondering if the people who shot the bomb where safe or even if the pilots health was affected by the bomb..

As I recall, there was a second plane on the Hiroshima run and it took the pics. Yes, everyone survived in the planes and there have been no reports of adverse affects on the aircraft crew. They were not THAT near the blast and were not there for long.
 
Yes, Tibbets recounts in the many WW2 documentaries I've watched over the years how he was instructed to make a "hard right" (or left) at a certain angle to avoid the effects of the blast. But it worked.
 
phinds said:
As I recall, there was a second plane on the Hiroshima run and it took the pics. Yes, everyone survived in the planes and there have been no reports of adverse affects on the aircraft crew. They were not THAT near the blast and were not there for long.

They screwed up, though, and only got one pic, the iconic one where the cloud slants to the right (or left) at the top.

They cheat, though, and always intermix footage of later bombings to the Hiroshima one to make it look more dramatic. Drives me nuts, because it's historical inaccuracy, and if there's anything I HATE, it's historical innacuracies.

In fact, I just watched a show yesterday, one of the "Secret war" shows on the military channel called "Hitlers atom bomb" where they said that the allies needed to destroy the plant in Norway making heavy water to prevent Hitler from being able to produce the Plutonium that was needed for an atom bomb. While they were saying that, they were showing animated footage from an entirely different documentary showing the uranium gun bomb used at Hiroshima. I mean, I'm not an expert, but the plutonium model was not the gun type, but that's what it seemed to allude to, so it bugged me. The series, "Sectret war," is great otherwise. Maybe someone can cross check my analysis.
 
https://www.newsweek.com/robert-redford-dead-hollywood-live-updates-2130559 Apparently Redford was a somewhat poor student, so was headed to Europe to study art and painting, but stopped in New York and studied acting. Notable movies include Barefoot in the Park (1967 with Jane Fonda), Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969, with Paul Newma), Jeremiah Johnson, the political drama The Candidate (both 1972), The Sting (1973 with Paul Newman), the romantic dramas The Way We Were (1973), and...
Back
Top