johnqwertyful
- 396
- 14
So is that 2 dollar/(mile/hour)=2 dollar hour/mile? What's a dollar hour? Is there a better way of handling this?
The discussion revolves around the interpretation of a proposed payment scheme of $2 for every mile per hour (mph) a person can run. Participants explore the implications of this rate, including unit conversions, mathematical reasoning, and the practicality of the incentive structure. The conversation touches on theoretical and conceptual aspects of speed and compensation.
Participants express a range of interpretations regarding the payment structure, with no consensus reached on the clarity or fairness of the proposed incentive. Multiple competing views remain on how to approach the problem mathematically and conceptually.
There are limitations in the assumptions made about the relationship between speed, distance, and time, as well as the definitions of units involved. Some mathematical steps remain unresolved, leading to different conclusions among participants.
johnqwertyful said:So is that 2 dollar/(mile/hour)=2 dollar hour/mile? What's a dollar hour? Is there a better way of handling this?
But how do the units work out? Is "mph" now somehow an irreducible unit?phinds said:You are over thinking it. It's just $2 per mph, so if I can run 12mph, which the latest marathon world record setter did recently, then you own me $24.
The unit is $/mph. The others are either gibberish or just plain wrong. You are trying to attach meaning to them, but they do not have the meaning you are attaching to them. IE: 1 mile per 4 hours is 1/4 mph and gets you paid $.50. Your alternative is just plain wrong. By flipping-over the mph to make h/mi, you are getting rid of the "per" while pretending not to.johnqwertyful said:Well to manipulate naively, 1 dollar/(x mile/y hour)=y hour dollar/x mile=y/x hour dollar/mile so we are at the first question.
However, with this you run into a problem. If you run 1 mile per 4 hours, you would run 4 times as slowly as someone who ran 1 mile per 1 hour, but you would get paid 4 times as much.
johnqwertyful said:So is that 2 dollar/(mile/hour)=2 dollar hour/mile? What's a dollar hour? Is there a better way of handling this?
I took it as the second one and was hoping to make $20 that way!BobG said:I take it you mean you'll pay $2 for every mile a person can run in one hour?
In other words, you're not going to pay Usain Bolt $50 for running 100 meters in 8.95 seconds?
Make an equation out of itto see whatt is going on.johnqwertyful said:So is that 2 dollar/(mile/hour)=2 dollar hour/mile? What's a dollar hour? Is there a better way of handling this?