Idempotent Matrices: Proving PQ+QP=0 implies PQ=QP=0

  • Thread starter Thread starter td21
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Matrix
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
3 replies · 3K views
td21
Gold Member
Messages
177
Reaction score
8

Homework Statement


P,Q is idempotent, i.e. P^2=P and Q^2=Q.
Show that: If PQ+QP=0, PQ=QP=0.


Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution


PQ+QP=0
PQ=-QP
PPQ=-PQP
PPQP=-PQPP
PQP=-PQP
PQP=0

I can only show PQP=0, but how to show PQ=QP=0?
Thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
td21 said:

Homework Statement


P,Q is idempotent, i.e. P^2=P and Q^2=Q.
Show that: If PQ+QP=0, PQ=QP=0.


Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution


PQ+QP=0
PQ=-QP
PPQ=-PQP
PPQP=-PQPP
PQP=-PQP
PQP=0

I can only show PQP=0, but how to show PQ=QP=0?
Thanks.

I really don't think you want me to tell you. You are SO close. Look at the third line where you showed PPQ=-PQP.
 
Dick said:
I really don't think you want me to tell you. You are SO close. Look at the third line where you showed PPQ=-PQP.
Thanks! But i still have trouble...
From 3rd line:
PPQ=-PQP
then
PQ=-PQP
PQQ=-PQPQ
PQ=-PQPQ
PQ(PQ+I)=0
PQ=0 or PQ=-I

Similarly,QP=0 or PQ=-I

Conclusion:
PQ=QP=0 or PQ=QP=-I

but still cannot show PQ=QP=0 ??
 
td21 said:
Thanks! But i still have trouble...
From 3rd line:
PPQ=-PQP
then
PQ=-PQP
PQQ=-PQPQ
PQ=-PQPQ
PQ(PQ+I)=0
PQ=0 or PQ=-I

Similarly,QP=0 or PQ=-I

Conclusion:
PQ=QP=0 or PQ=QP=-I

but still cannot show PQ=QP=0 ??

You completely overshot the goal. You showed PQ=(-PQP) and PQP=0. Just substitute the second into the first. So PQ=(-0)=0.