Identifying sign conventions for torque and tension

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on determining the correct sign conventions for torque and tension in a pulley system with two boxes. It highlights that tensions can be treated as having opposite signs, regardless of their directions in the coordinate system. The torque produced by each force is calculated using the vector cross product, resulting in one torque pointing out of the screen and the other into the screen. A participant expresses confusion over differing sign conventions and acknowledges a previous algebraic error. The conversation concludes with a suggestion for learning to write equations in LaTeX for clarity.
droidofthevoid
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
My question arises from trying to get the correct sign convention for a pulley that has two boxes attached by a massless rope. one box is to the left of the pulley and the other box is hanging down below the pulley.

If I take the counter clockwise direction to be negative, and set up my coordinate system as having the pulley at the origin, will the tensions as seen by the pulley both be negative because one is in the negative x direction and the other is in the negative y direction?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Don't think of the tension as being in the x or y coordinate system. There's no gravity pulling on the rope, or other forces besides the tension, so you can just say that the tensions have opposite signs.

Perhaps it might help to think that one is CCW, and one is CW.

It's been awhile since I did mechanics, but hopefully this helps.
 
  • Like
Likes droidofthevoid
Thank You
 
Are you acquainted with the notion of torque as a vector, defined by a vector cross product?

The torque produced by ##\vec F_1## is ##\vec \tau_1 = \vec r_1 \times \vec F_1## which points in the +z direction (out of the screen), according to the right-hand rule.
The torque produced by ##\vec F_2## is ##\vec \tau_2 = \vec r_2 \times \vec F_2## which points in the -z direction (into the screen).

More explicitly in terms of unit vectors, ##\vec \tau_1 = (r_1 \hat y) \times (- F_1 \hat x) = - r_1 F_1( \hat y \times \hat x) = - r_1 F_1 (- \hat z) = + r_1 F_1 \hat z##.

I leave ##\vec \tau_2## as an exercise. :oldwink:

pulley.gif
 
  • Like
Likes droidofthevoid
jtbell said:
Are you acquainted with the notion of torque as a vector, defined by a vector cross product?

The torque produced by ##\vec F_1## is ##\vec \tau_1 = \vec r_1 \times \vec F_1## which points in the +z direction (out of the screen), according to the right-hand rule.
The torque produced by ##\vec F_2## is ##\vec \tau_2 = \vec r_2 \times \vec F_2## which points in the -z direction (into the screen).

More explicitly in terms of unit vectors, ##\vec \tau_1 = (r_1 \hat y) \times (- F_1 \hat x) = - r_1 F_1( \hat y \times \hat x) = - r_1 F_1 (- \hat z) = + r_1 F_1 \hat z##.

I leave ##\vec \tau_2## as an exercise. :oldwink:

View attachment 92798

Yes, I am aware of the Torque vector notion. I was just a little thrown off because I had a question where clockwise motion was chosen as positive as opposed to negative. Instinctively I assumed that any answer found in the positive clockwise direction would be of opposite value in the negative counterclockwise direction, however, I made a sign error in my algebra when solving.

To answer your question regarding ##\vec \tau_2##

##\vec \tau_2 = (r_2 \hat x) \times (- F_2\hat y) = - r_1 F_2( \hat x \times \hat y) = - r_1 F_1 ( \hat z) = - r_2 F_2\hat z##.

To be honest, I just copied your code for the equation you wrote since I don't really know how to write equations in the forum yet. Is there a simpler way to write equations with vector hats or is this the basic format?Thank you again for your input!
 
For a tutorial on doing equations in LaTeX, go to the Info menu at the top right of this page, choose "Help/How-To" and then "LaTeX Primer". To see the LaTeX code for a posted equation, control-click it if you're on a Mac or (I think) right-click it if you're on Windows, then choose Show Math As --> TeX Commands. (might be different on Windows).
 
Awesome! Thank you again!
 
Back
Top