Is Our Understanding of Gravity and Entropy Incomplete?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Chronos
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Entropy
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the notion that the universe began in a highly ordered state and has become increasingly disordered over time, raising questions about the completeness of current theories of gravity and entropy. Participants express discomfort with relying on untestable concepts like strings and extra dimensions, suggesting they complicate understanding without providing observable validation. There is a debate about the definition of "order" and "states of existence," with some arguing that galaxies represent a form of order rather than disorder. The conversation highlights a tension between perceived chaos in the early universe and the structured formations observed today. Ultimately, the dialogue reflects a desire for a coherent framework that aligns with observable phenomena.
Chronos
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
11,420
Reaction score
751
It is fairly evident the universe originated in a more highly ordered state than we presently observe. It is also fairly evident it has become increasingly disordered over time [e.g., expansion and those inexplicable clumps of matter called galaxies, stars, etc.]. I am therefore forced to conclude the number of possible states of existence have increased over time. The concept of action and reaction [blame Newton and Laplace] seem to insist current explanations for gravity and entropy are incomplete. I am very uncomfortable having to rely upon untestable explanations. Strings and extra dimensions are not very satisfying. They appear to require a higher order of 'law' that is inherently impossible to validate by observation. The long and the short of it... a universe without predictable consequences [causality] cannot exist in my local reference frame.

Thoughts?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
IIRC, according to BBT, there was much more homogeneity to the universe once upon a time. no large atoms, only H and maybe some He. just clouds of gas waiting for gravity to do its magic.

by "order", do you mean neat rows of similar things? do you mean repetition? do you mean "information" ?

what do you mean by "states of existence" ?
do you mean thermodynamic microstates? since that's what entropy deals with?

Edit--------------------------------------------------------------------

how are galaxies considered "disorder"? It seems like the universe went from conceptually disordered (a bunch of spread out, whizzing-around, light atoms in a gas) to what we would conceive of as "order". Solids, crystals, planets, regular motion about centers of gravity, etc.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Publication: Redox-driven mineral and organic associations in Jezero Crater, Mars Article: NASA Says Mars Rover Discovered Potential Biosignature Last Year Press conference The ~100 authors don't find a good way this could have formed without life, but also can't rule it out. Now that they have shared their findings with the larger community someone else might find an explanation - or maybe it was actually made by life.
TL;DR Summary: In 3 years, the Square Kilometre Array (SKA) telescope (or rather, a system of telescopes) should be put into operation. In case of failure to detect alien signals, it will further expand the radius of the so-called silence (or rather, radio silence) of the Universe. Is there any sense in this or is blissful ignorance better? In 3 years, the Square Kilometre Array (SKA) telescope (or rather, a system of telescopes) should be put into operation. In case of failure to detect...
This thread is dedicated to the beauty and awesomeness of our Universe. If you feel like it, please share video clips and photos (or nice animations) of space and objects in space in this thread. Your posts, clips and photos may by all means include scientific information; that does not make it less beautiful to me (n.b. the posts must of course comply with the PF guidelines, i.e. regarding science, only mainstream science is allowed, fringe/pseudoscience is not allowed). n.b. I start this...
Back
Top