Is the balance of forces equation correct for a tube immersed in alcohol?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the balance of forces for a tube immersed in alcohol, focusing on the equation M*g + p_0*A = ρ*g*(A*d) + p*A. Participants explore the relationship between internal and external pressures, referencing Stevin's law and Boyle's law to establish connections between pressure and gas volume. The need for a constant temperature assumption during gas compression is highlighted. A key point is the understanding that pressure variations under a liquid surface are isobaric at the same depth, regardless of horizontal distance from the tube. Ultimately, the participants work through the problem collaboratively, leading to a clearer understanding of the force balance and pressure relationships.
ValeForce46
Messages
40
Reaction score
3
Homework Statement
A tube of mass ##M= 18 kg ##, section ##A= 300 cm^2 ## and lenght ##l= 200 cm ## is sealed to the top and opened to the bottom. Initially the tube contains only air at a pressure ##p_0= 1 bar ##, occupying the whole volume ##A*l ## (see picture a). Then, the tube is leaning on a surface of alcol (density ##ρ=0.8 g/cm3 ##) and, keeping the tube vertically, it is immersed until it reaches a position of balance. In this process the air inside the tube is compressed (see picture b).
In conditions of equilibrium, calculate:
a)the pressure ##p ## of the air inside the tube;
b)the difference of level ##d ## between the surface of the alcol inside and outside the tube;
c)the length ##b ## of the tube which emerges.
Relevant Equations
Stevino's Law ##p=p_0+ρ*g*h ##
Force caused by pressure ##F=p*A##
This is a problem from a past exam.
For point a)
the balance between force should be given by the following equation
$$M*g+p_0*A=ρ*g*(A*d)+p*A$$
But I still have two unknown values...
I know that pressure outside the tube at depth d is
$$p(d)=p_0+ρ*g*d$$
and this has to be equal to the pressure at depth d inside the tube, because that's a free surface.
What do I do now? Is the equation of the balance of the forces correct?
Fisica.png
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
Physics news on Phys.org
Hello VF, :welcome: !

ValeForce46 said:
What do I do now?
You will need something to link the pressure inside the tube to the gas volume. Any suggestions ? :smile:
Is the equation of the balance of the forces correct?
Looks good
 
Well... The only two things that jump in my mind are Boyle's law and work. I don't think you report on those because I can't figure out how I should use them. It's not even specified if that is a isothermal process...
 
ValeForce46 said:
Well... The only two things that jump in my mind are Boyle's law and work. I don't think you report on those because I can't figure out how I should use them. It's not even specified if that is a isothermal process...
You may assume that the temperature of the gas and everything else around it remains constant throughout the compression of the gas.

On edit:
Upon closer inspection, why is this equation correct?
ValeForce46 said:
##M*g+p_0*A=ρ*g*(A*d)+p*A##
The weight of the tube ##Mg## must be equal to the weight of the displaced fluid ##\rho V_{under}g##. What is the volume ##V_{under}## of the tube under the surface of the fluid?
 
Last edited:
so if I use Boyle's law I get
$$p_0*(A*l)=p*A*(b+d)$$
that is
$$p_0*l=p*(b+d)$$
But now what should I do to get the pressure ##p##?
 
What does Stevin's (Stevino's) law say about the variation of pressure at a given point under the surface of a liquid? Does it matter whether that point is under the immersed tube or horizontally off by some distance?
 
Stevin's law says that the variation of pressure under the surface of a liquid at the depth h is ##Δp=ρ*g*h##. If I'm not wrong, it doesn't matter if that point is under the immersed tube or horizontally off by some distance, because every parallel plane to the free surface is isobaric, right? But this should be valid only if the depth is ##h>d## (in this situation)... Maybe I'm blind but I can't still see the solution :-(
 
First please read my edited post #4 about the force balance at equilibrium and fix your equation.
ValeForce46 said:
Stevin's law says that the variation of pressure under the surface of a liquid at the depth h is ##Δp=ρ*g*h##. If I'm not wrong, it doesn't matter if that point is under the immersed tube or horizontally off by some distance, because every parallel plane to the free surface is isobaric, right?
Right.
ValeForce46 said:
But this should be valid only if the depth is ##h>d## (in this situation)... Maybe I'm blind but I can't still see the solution :-(
Consider a point right at the lip of the submerged tube. Go a bit off to the right and a bit off to the left and write the same pressure in two different ways. Do you see it now? :oldsmile:
 
I THINK I FINALLY GOT IT. Thank you for your time and patience :oldbiggrin:
 
Back
Top