Is There a Meissner-Like Effect for Electric Fields?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the possibility of a Meissner-like effect for electric fields, akin to how superconductors repel magnetic fields. It is clarified that while superconductors can prevent magnetic fields from penetrating their surfaces, a similar phenomenon cannot occur for electric fields. Gauss's law indicates that charges within a perfect conductor redistribute to the surface, allowing electric field lines to extend outside. Participants argue that electric field lines are fundamentally different from magnetic lines, as they cannot be closed loops. Ultimately, the consensus is that a material capable of completely preventing electric field lines from entering or leaving does not exist.
RGClark
Messages
82
Reaction score
0
A superconductor repels a magnetic field by the Meissner effect. Is there a similar effect for an electric field? Note this is something different than just an insulator not allowing a current to flow.
By the Meissner effect, if you have a hollow sphere that is superconducting and you have a permanent magnet inside it, then the magnetic field still exists inside the sphere: iron fillings on the inside would be attracted to it, etc. However, no magnetic field would be detected *outside* the superconductor from this magnet inside. And the same would hold in reverse with the permanent magnet outside the superconductor.
Note that Gauss's law also would not allow you to accomplish this for the electric field by using a hollow perfectly conducting sphere. The effect of a charge inside a closed, hollow perfect conductor is that the charge is redistributed to the surface of the conductor. But then the electric field lines will still extend outside the perfect conductor due to this charge on the surface.
What I'm looking for is for the electric field lines to be prevented from entering or leaving the body.


Bob Clark
 
Physics news on Phys.org
This is not possible for electric lines of force.
It is possible for magnetic ones because they are always closed lines.
Imagine a positive charge. All lines come out of the charge to finish in a negative charge or at infinity. If you had a material with the properties you described, you could put a box of this material around the charge and forbade le lines of field to finish somewhere.
Then this substance do not exist.
 
Back
Top