Is there a short book on learning proofs?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Saladsamurai
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Book Proofs Short
AI Thread Summary
A discussion emerged about finding a concise resource for learning mathematical proofs, particularly for an engineering student facing challenges in a graduate mathematical methods course. The student expressed a need for a quick way to grasp proof techniques, especially since proofs were unexpectedly featured on an exam. Suggestions included the book "How to Prove It" by Daniel Velleman, noted for its clarity and brevity, with the recommendation that only certain chapters may be necessary for understanding. Key strategies for approaching proofs were highlighted, such as knowing definitions thoroughly, using theorems, and practicing proof techniques like contradiction. The importance of counterexamples in disproving statements was also emphasized. Overall, the community provided resources and techniques aimed at helping the student prepare for their upcoming final exam.
Saladsamurai
Messages
3,009
Reaction score
7
Is there a "short" book on learning proofs?

I realize that is probably an oxymoron :smile: I know that proofs take getting used to and lots of practice. However, I am in a bind here. I am an engineering student, so as you might imagine, I have almost never been asked to prove something mathematically. However, I am taking a graduate mathematical methods course and my professor thinks he is really funny. We never do anything proof-like in class, but they were all over our exam. Naturally, not one person out of 80 answered any of them.

I am kind of up to the challenge though. The problem is, there are only 4 weeks left until the final. I know I cannot completely master these things in such a short time, but I would like to make an effort to learn enough that I can at least write something when see one. I was hoping there might be a short book, or web resource that could give like the "top ten" approaches or things to look for when starting a proof. Even a if there is a longer text, but someone knows of a few good chapters that could give me an edge. Maybe the introductory chapters of a book you have read were the most helpful, or helped you learn how to get into the mindset of doing these.

Any suggestions are appreciated. Thanks! :smile:
 
Physics news on Phys.org


You might want to take a look at the Wikipedia article on Mathematical proof. Some of the external links at the end of the article might be what you're looking for.
 
Last edited by a moderator:


the basic rule for doing a proof is to know the definitions cold.

i.e. to prove every wozzle is a wizzle, you just start by writing down the precise definition of a wozzle, and also that of a wizzle, and then you try to see why one being true forces the other also to be true.

in a math class, to prove something is true, you often have a theorem that has that something as its consequence. to apply it in a specific case, you then check that the hypotheses of that theorem hold in that case.
 


proofs & refutations by lakatos. it's probably not quite the most "short" or elementary, but it's good
 


a basic proof technique is by contradiction. so for this you must practice negating statements. e.g. to disprove that every wozzle is a wizzle, you must show there is at least one wozzle which is not a wizzle. so you only have to find one counterexample.

e.g. to disprove the false version of the fundamental theorem of aLGEBRA THAT EVERY COMPLEX POLYNOMIAL HAS A ROOT, just EXHIBIT THE constant POLYNOMIAL f(z) = 1.
 


You could try 'How To Prove It', but that may be too basic to help, I can't be sure since you're an engineering student yet you're taking a high level maths class. It's by David Vellemen.

EDIT: Oops! Someone above recommended it already. Still, it's pretty good. Builds from the basics, if that's what you're looking for.
 


Thanks for all of the replies folks! :smile: I found a copy of How to Prove It for really cheap.
 

Similar threads

Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
6K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
39
Views
7K
Replies
4
Views
6K
Replies
5
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top