Is This Differential Equation Misplaced in the Precalculus Forum?

  • Thread starter Thread starter fan_103
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a differential equation presented in a precalculus forum, raising questions about its appropriateness for that category. The equation, (x^2+y^2)y'=xy, was attempted to be solved by a user, who showed some steps but made a critical error by not including "dx" on the right side during integration. Another participant clarified that the equation is not separable but is a homogeneous first-order equation, suggesting a substitution method for solving it. The conversation also highlights confusion about the appropriate forum for such mathematical inquiries, with suggestions to post in "Calculus and Beyond." The thread emphasizes the importance of proper notation and understanding the classification of differential equations.
fan_103
Messages
24
Reaction score
0
1.Solve this differential equation



2.(x^2+y^2)y'=xy



3. Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What have you tried? The rules in this forum state that you must show some effort before we'll help you out.
 
Ok mate I have tried it
(x^2+y^2)dy/dx=xy

Divide by y*(x^2+y^2) : 1/y dy/dx= x/(x^2+y^2).

\int {1/y} dy= 1/2\int {x/(x^2+y^2)}

My answer is y=A \sqrt{x^2+y^2}.
 
Last edited:
I don't see how you get that answer from the equation above it.
There are various classes of differential equations that can be solved.
This one is in one of those classes.
It's probably more instructive to search for which class it is in yourself.
 
Can anyone help me please its very important!
 
fan_103 said:
Ok mate I have tried it
(x^2+y^2)dy/dx=xy

Divide by y*(x^2+y^2) : 1/y dy/dx= x/(x^2+y^2).

\int {1/y} dy= 1/2\int {x/(x^2+y^2)}
You don't have a "dx" on the right

My answer is y=A \sqrt{x^2+y^2}.
That may seem like a technical point but it would have reminded you that you are integrating on the right with respect to x and y is some (unknown) function of x, not a constant. This is NOT a separable equation- that is you cannot get only x on one side of the equation and only y on the other.

It is, however, a "homogeneous" first order equation. If you divide both sides of the equation by x^2, you get
(1+ \left(\frac{y}{x}\right)^2)dy= \frac{y}{x}dx
Let u= y/x. Don't for get to replace dy: y= ux so dy= xdu+ udx.

Why was this posted under "Precalculus"?
 
I forgot to write the dx on the right.
Thanks a lot mate!Really appreciate ur effort!

Why was this posted under "Precalculus"? Where should I post these kind of questions...
 
fan_103 said:
I forgot to write the dx on the right.
Thanks a lot mate!Really appreciate ur effort!

Why was this posted under "Precalculus"? Where should I post these kind of questions...


In Calculus and Beyond...
 

Similar threads

Back
Top