Lewis structure for Nitrogen Dioxide

5 replies · 15K views · last reply
Bipolarity
Messages
773
Reaction score
2
I am pondering on what the correct Lewis structure(s) for Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) may be...
I have come up with 7 possible structures, but am unsure which are correct and which are not. I have compiled a small list of notes for your convenience and they are all in this picture.

Which structure(s) are correct and which are incorrect and why?

http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/202/nitrogendioxide.jpg/
 
Its a resonance structure that is a combination of structures 3 and 4:
Two Lewis structures of nitrogen dioxide, NO2, in brackets joined by a double-headed resonance arrow; each shows N bonded to two O atoms with lone pairs as dots.

Think about benzene. Its lewis structure isn't actually this:
Skeletal structural formula of benzene drawn as a hexagon of carbon atoms labelled C, each bonded to one hydrogen atom labelled H, with alternating double bonds shown inside the ring.

in reality its Lewis structure is this:
Two Kekulé structures of benzene, each a hexagon of carbon atoms with alternating double bonds and one H on each carbon, joined by a double-headed resonance arrow.

because the double bonds are constantly changing position.
 
CrimpJiggler said:
Its a resonance structure that is a combination of structures 3 and 4:
Two resonance Lewis structures of nitrogen dioxide, NO2, in brackets joined by a double-headed arrow; each shows N bonded to two O atoms with lone pairs as dots and one unpaired electron on N.

Think about benzene. Its lewis structure isn't actually this:
Skeletal structural formula of benzene: a hexagonal ring of six carbon atoms, each labelled C and bonded to one hydrogen atom labelled H, with alternating double bonds in the ring.

in reality its Lewis structure is this:
Two resonance structures of benzene drawn as skeletal hexagons with C and H labels and alternating double bonds, joined by a double-headed equilibrium arrow.

because the double bonds are constantly changing position.

But shouldn't the electrons be placed on the more electronegative atom, i.e. oxygen, so that nitrogen gets the lone pair, giving it Lewis structures 1 and 2?
 
It is chemical resonance, as CrimpJiggler said, but its not so much that the electrons are in constant fluctuation, but rather the odd electrons that could be bonded or non-bonded are involved in a sort of delocalized electron orbital that surrounds the entire molecule, apparently the delocalization of the electrons actually lowers their potential, making the resonant molecule more stable than either standard lewis formation.
 
In fact, you any valence structure which is compartible with none of the orbitals being filled by more than two electrons and a total of 23 electrons is valid and will contribute to some extent to the true wavefunction of the molecule. The relative importance of the structures depends not only on the molecule itself but also on the orbital basis considered (i.e. s and p type or hybrids, orthogonalized or not).
Nevertheless the two structures shown in the video will probably be most important, at least for a qualitative description of the molecule.