The discussion centers on a misleading article claiming Mars is 2-4 million years old, which participants clarify is incorrect, as Mars is billions of years old. Concerns are raised about the potential for misinterpretation due to poor editing and lack of scientific knowledge among reporters. The original article's focus was on Mars's formation rather than its lifespan, leading to confusion. Participants express embarrassment over the misunderstanding but appreciate the mature nature of the forum. Overall, the conversation highlights the importance of critical reading and verifying sources in scientific discussions.
#1
joesmith
11
0
Recently I saw this in the news...any thoughts on this?
jhd as joesmith
Was this not posted earlier today already? Mars is definitely not 2-4mya, it's formation may have occurred over that time frame but it is billions of years old
#3
joesmith
11
0
Sir I searched this Forum with every tool available to me.
I will look at the credentials of the author of the Article.
If I am incorrect then I owe everyone an apology.
Perhaps I read the article wrongg,,,perhaps the guy who wrote it is an idiot.
Any way you look at it ,,,It is I who must suffer??
How do I screen my news?
Who should I listen to?
What is that I smell cooking in the kitchen,,
come and gti it,,,,,,
j
#4
Nik_2213
1,218
493
It may have been a victim of sub-editing, where a vital phrase just fell out.
Unfortunately, too few reporters & editors have even a glimmering of scientific education...
Indeed, articles like this could be easily misread to mean that Mars formed to its present state over the past 3my.
#6
joesmith
11
0
arrrrgggghhh...now the guys on the Mars blog ,,,ah well,,Silence is Golden
jhd
#7
JaredJames
2,818
22
This was posted earlier today, it's been deleted by the looks of it.
The article was actually regarding the formation of Mars, not the life span. Exceedingly misleading thread title both in the original deleted thread and this one. Although at least you are asking a question not just posting an article under a false title.
#8
joesmith
11
0
Thanks guys,,,,,I feel OK,,,,,,just embarrassing..
Sorry,,,,,,there was a time I would have been pissed,,guess I grew out
of it.
-------------
and,,,,,The Audience here is very Mature.
jhd
#9
JaredJames
2,818
22
Watch your language!
#10
joesmith
11
0
JaredJames
I apologize for my bad language..
I Love this Forum,,,made up of truly mature people!
a joe in Texas