Measuring 45 Minutes with Ropes & Liquid

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gokul43201
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Liquid Measuring
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a puzzle involving two cloth ropes of varying thickness and length, which wick colored liquid at a non-constant rate. The objective is to measure 45 minutes using these ropes and the liquid. The solution involves dipping one end of the first rope and both ends of the second rope into the liquid simultaneously. The second rope will completely wick through in 30 minutes, at which point the first rope will have 30 minutes of wick-time remaining. After 30 minutes, the other end of the first rope is dipped, allowing it to wick from both ends, which will take an additional 15 minutes. This method effectively measures a total of 45 minutes. The discussion also touches on the nuances of wicking rates and the implications of simultaneous wicking.
Gokul43201
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
7,207
Reaction score
25
You have two cloth ropes. The ropes have non-uniform thicknesses and are of different lengths. You also have a bucket of colored liquid. When you dip an end of a rope into the liquid, the colored liquid wicks through the rope, progressing through it at some non-constant rate. The total wick-time for the ropes is 1 hour each. How would you measure 45 minutes using only the ropes and the liquid ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Old puzzle.
 
oops sorry...just ignore it. I'm fairly new here and haven't looked through all the older stuff.
 
this puzzle might be old, but i would still like to know the answer.
 
vikasj007 said:
this puzzle might be old, but i would still like to know the answer.

Sure thing : but let me give you a BIG hint instead. What happens when you simultaneously dip both ends of a rope in the liquid ?
 
im sure you just fold one in half and dip the ends in the water.

after its full, you can dip the other rope in two spots, and it will wick in 15 mins.

one semantic problem is that once a wicked part meets another wicked part the wicking rate wouldn't increase at the ends. the 15 minute timer wouldn't be exact.
 
For closure on this...here's the solution :

START : Dip one end of rope 1 and both ends of rope 2. Rope 2 will wick through in 30 mins. So rope 1 has exhausted 30 mins of its length and has 30 mins of wick-time left. At the instant that rope 2 completes wicking through (after 30 mins), dip the other end of rope 1. So now a half-hour rope has liquid wicking through from both ends, and hence will last 15 mins.

TOTAL TIME = 30 +15 =45 mins exactly !

No probkem !
 
Back
Top