Motion of a Uniform Chain falling I desperatly

In summary, a uniform heavy chain of length "a" hangs initially with a part of length, "b", hanging over the edge of a table. The remaining part of length a-b is coiled up at the edge of the table. If the chain is released, the speed of the chain when the last link leaves the end of the table can be found using conservation of momentum with variable mass, resulting in the equation [2g(a^3-b^3)/(3a^2)]^1/2. Alternatively, the problem can also be solved using conservation of energy or Lagrangian equations.
  • #1
^_^physicist
235
1
Motion of a Uniform Chain falling...I desperatly need help

Homework Statement


A uniform heavy chain of length "a" hangs initially with a part of length, "b", hanging over the edge of a table. The remaining part of length a-b is coiled up at the edge of the table. If the chain is released show that the speed of the chain when the last link leaves the end of the table is [2g(a^3-b^3)/(3a^2)]^1/2

Homework Equations


mg=m*dv/dt+dm/dt*v

The Attempt at a Solution


I have tried many times to do this problem, following the above equation, which my professor claims is correct for this problem; however, I get stuck everytime in the following situation (which my professor also claims is correct):

From the begining

Let m= z*dm/dx, than note that dm/dx=y. m=z*y. Than dm/dt=dz/dt*y.

z*y*g=z*y*dv/dt + v*dz/dt*y

Note that dv/dt= (d^2Z/dt^2)
(note from now on that z(dot)= dz/dt, as is common in this notation)

So dv/dt= (dz(dot)/dz)*z(dot)
Again note that d/dz{(1/2)*(z(dot))^2} = dz(dot)/dz * z(dot)

And then I get stuck, as I will end up in a loop of doing the same things over and over again. Worse yet, my professor told me explictly that this is what must be done for doing this problem using the equation given, and that I will (after I figure out the next step), need to use the method of frobenius to solve the problem.

The alternative method of solving this, which he himself did mention, is to use largrange or hamaltionan mechanics (but he said we would have to figure those out on our own, as he hasn't refreshed himself on the topic).
------

If I could get a hand setting this up with largrange, that would be awesome, I know that I need to some how split the problem into two to use the largrange, additionally I believe that I will need to take into account that it only has two degrees of freedom (motion on a plane); however, I can't figure out how to set up the largragian from that (I am a pretty inexperanced with the method; however, I would much rather learn to do this problem in largrange, than trying to muscule my way through the rest of the problem, when I don't quite understand how to exactly go about it).Thank you in advanced for anyhelp.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
^_^physicist said:
From the begining

Let m= z*dm/dx, than note that dm/dx=y. m=z*y. Than dm/dt=dz/dt*y.

Sorry, I can't follow your notation here.

In m = z.dm/dx you seem to be using "m" for two different things in the same equation, and you don't say what x y and z are - so its hard to tell whether this is right or wrong.

The equation your prof gave you is applying conservation of momentum with variable mass. In that equation, m is the mass of the chain that is off the table.

As to alternative methods, you don't really need to use Lagrangian or Hamiltonian equations for this, but you could use conservation of energy.
 
  • #3
just a clarification, it should be m = z*dm/dx, where y=dm/dx, thus m= z*y. We have to do this because the mass falling is increasing over time.

------

I have tried energy conservation, and I end up getting that v= [2g*(a-b)]^1/2, which according to the book and my professor, is wrong.
 
  • #4
Since the chain is coiled, shouldn't the term [itex]m\frac{dv}{dt}[/itex] vanish? If so then this becomes an easy seperable DE.
My argument goes as follows: Your main equation comes from
[itex]F=\frac{dP}{dt}\Longrightarrow mg=m\frac{dv}{dt}+\frac{dm}{dt}v[/itex]
[itex]F=mg[/itex] is the force pulling the chain off the table and since the chain is COILED this means that at any instant only an infinitesimal amount of mass is being jerked by this force. Consequently the m in the [itex]F=mg[/itex] term refers to all of the mass already off the table contributing to the force, while the m in the [itex]m\frac{dv}{dt}[/itex] term refers to the infinitesimal mass whose momentum is being affected by this force F. These m values are not the same.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
Let the chain have mass m per unit length and let x be the length off the table. The mass of the hanging part of the chain is mx.

Force = rate of change of momentum:

mxg = d/dt(mx x') = mxx" + mx'^2

So the equation of motion is

xx" + x'^2 = gx ... (1)

Boundary conditions: at t = 0, x = b and x' = 0

To solve (1), let y = (1/2)x'^2

Then y' = x'x"

x" = y' / x' = (dy/dt) / (dx/dt) = dy/dx

So (1) becomes

x dy/dx + 2y = gx ... (2)

which is solvable by the standard "trick": let p = dy/dx, differentiate wrt x to get an DE connecting p and x, solve, then use (2) to eliminate p.

Doing that gives

gx^3 - 3yx^2 = C where C is the constant of integration

and it's all downhill after that.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
Cool, thanks for the help (Your explanation was much better than when my professor was trying to explain how to approach this problem).
 

1. What is the motion of a uniform chain falling?

The motion of a uniform chain falling can be described as a combination of both translational and rotational motion. As the chain falls, each link experiences a downward force due to gravity, causing it to accelerate downwards. At the same time, the chain also experiences torque due to the weight of the links, causing it to rotate as it falls.

2. What factors affect the motion of a uniform chain falling?

The motion of a uniform chain falling is affected by several factors, including the length and mass of the chain, the strength of gravity, and any external forces acting on the chain. Additionally, the type of surface the chain is falling on can also impact its motion, as friction can affect the rate at which the chain falls.

3. How is the speed of a chain falling calculated?

The speed of a chain falling can be calculated using the equation v = √(2gh), where v is the speed in meters per second, g is the acceleration due to gravity in meters per second squared, and h is the height of the fall in meters. This equation assumes that there is no air resistance and that the chain is falling vertically.

4. What is the difference between a uniform chain and a non-uniform chain?

A uniform chain is one in which each link has the same mass and size, while a non-uniform chain has links of varying sizes and masses. This difference can affect the motion of the chain when it falls, as a non-uniform chain may experience more irregularities and inconsistencies in its motion compared to a uniform chain.

5. How does the motion of a uniform chain falling compare to other objects?

The motion of a uniform chain falling is similar to that of other objects in free fall, such as a ball or a feather. However, the unique shape and structure of a chain can cause it to experience different types of motion, such as coiling or twisting, as it falls. Additionally, the fact that a chain is composed of multiple linked segments can also impact its motion in ways that are different from other objects.

Similar threads

  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
902
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
504
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
15
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
2K
Back
Top