Multimeter Peak Voltage Reading

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around measuring the peak voltage of AC current produced by a motorcycle alternator using a multimeter. Participants explore various methods for obtaining peak voltage readings, including the use of RMS values and alternative measuring tools like oscilloscopes.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Experimental/applied

Main Points Raised

  • One participant suggests using the formula Vp = Vrms * sqrt(2) to calculate peak voltage from RMS readings, questioning if multimeters display RMS values.
  • Another participant confirms that most multimeters read RMS unless stated otherwise and asserts that readings will not fluctuate rapidly.
  • A different participant argues that using the max function on a multimeter will not yield a true peak reading, but rather the maximum fluctuations in the RMS value.
  • Several participants recommend using an oscilloscope for accurate peak voltage readings, noting that only certain multimeters can provide true RMS readings for non-sine wave inputs.
  • One participant discusses the specifics of the crank position sensor and cautions against assuming a sine wave output, emphasizing the need for peak measurements.
  • Another participant suggests a method involving a diode in series with the meter to measure alternator output at various RPMs, highlighting the potential for inaccuracies in this approach.
  • There is a request for clarification on the specific motorcycle model being discussed to provide more tailored advice.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the reliability of using RMS values to determine peak voltage, with some asserting that it is not valid for non-sine wave signals. There is no consensus on the best method for measuring peak voltage, as various approaches are proposed and debated.

Contextual Notes

Participants note limitations regarding the assumptions about the waveform produced by the alternator and the capabilities of different multimeters. The discussion includes references to specific components and measurement techniques that may not be universally applicable.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for motorcycle enthusiasts, electronics hobbyists, and individuals interested in measuring AC voltage in non-standard applications.

Hondaboi1729
Hi,

I need to find the peak voltage of the ac current produced by the sensor connected to the alternator on my motorcycle. The workshop manual recommended a peak voltage adapter which goes on a multimeter.
I don't want to buy this expensive thing.
I was wondering since Vp=Vrms*sqrt (2). I can just use the reading on the multimeter and multiply it by sqrt (2). However when you are measuring the AC voltage with a multimeter does it display the RMS?;The readings aren't going to fluctuate rapidly as the voltage of the AC changes is it?

Secondly I also thought if the above didn't work I could just use the max function on the multimeter to work it out? That way at the end the peak voltage will be displayed. Is this a good idea?

Thanks
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Hondaboi1729 said:
However when you are measuring the AC voltage with a multimeter does it display the RMS?;

most multimeters read RMS unless otherwise stated

Hondaboi1729 said:
The readings aren't going to fluctuate rapidly as the voltage of the AC changes is it?

no
 
Hondaboi1729 said:
Secondly I also thought if the above didn't work I could just use the max function on the multimeter to work it out? That way at the end the peak voltage will be displayed. Is this a good idea?

That's not going to give you a peak reading, it's only going to give you max fluctuations in the RMS value
 
Use an oscilloscope. Way back when.. I was in electronics development and I used a 'scope for everything.
 
davenn said:
most multimeters read RMS unless otherwise stated

They will be calibrated to display RMS values for a sine wave input. Only more expensive multimeters with a true RMS feature will actually give RMS readings for a non-sine wave input.

You can only get the peak value by multiplying the RMS value by sqrt(2) if you have a sine wave signal. As the alternator instructions specify using a peak-reading probe we can assume you don't have a sine wave signal and you can't multiply a multimeter reading by root 2 to get the peak value.

As already stated the best way to read the peak value is an oscilloscope. If it's a reading you will need to keep making you could cheaply build your own peak probe with a signal diode, a capacitor and, if needed, a resistor. If I did that I'd still want to use a scope the first time to check the probe reading.
 
GrahamN-UK said:
They will be calibrated to display RMS values for a sine wave input. Only more expensive multimeters with a true RMS feature will actually give RMS readings for a non-sine wave input.

yes that is correct
 
When you say the sensor attached to the alternator I'm assuming you're referring to the crank position sensor (some service manuals refer to is as the pickup coil, signal generator, and numerous other names)? If so you can't conclusively rely on simply multiplying your meter's Vac reading by sqrt(2) due to the actual output of the coil. It's a pulsing Hall Effect sensor that connects to the semiconductor switch inside your Ignition Control Module (on older CDIs it's connected to an SCR gate; this may be different on modern vehicles with computerized ECUs). If you put an oscilloscope across it you'll see it's not a perfect sine wave.

As far as cost, modern major manufacturers offer them at fairly reasonable prices. You can also find numerous articles online about making your own. When it comes to measuring the crank sensor you definitely need to be taking a peak measurement otherwise you're shooting in the dark. The meter's "normal" Vac reading, which is basically the meter's best attempt at RMS unless you have one of the expensive true-RMS meters, can be indicative but not conclusive.
 
Since you're doing this test should i assume something isn't working ?Does the manual direct you to make this measurement "open circuit", that is with the wire that goes to voltage regulator unplugged from the alternator stator ?

If so
Connect a diode in series with your meter and set it for DC.
Then measure alternator output at several RPM's writing down RPM and volts.
Your alternator will charge the meter's input capacitance to peak voltage several times each revolution
and that's what you meter will report.
It's not exact
but since you're probably going to get around fifty volts a volt or so error won't matter much.
If you plot volts vs RPM on a piece of graph paper you should get an almost straight line.

BUT
If this is an in-place measurement with regulator and battery connected and working properly
you'll get a lower voltage, probably just a little more than battery voltage. Be aware the diode will lower your reading by a fraction of a volt.
If you get fifty volts probably the regulator has failed or there's a fuse blown someplace.Lastly
Read battery voltage . It should increase when engine is running,
that's a "poor man's quick check" . If it settles around 14 volts then everything looks okay...
Real poor men who don't have a voltmeter just observe brightness of at the headlight at night , out of the city where our eyes can detect the subtle change in brightness .. (or darkness if it's a Lucas .)old jim
 
It would really help if we knew what bike you were working on
 
  • #10

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
8K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
5K
Replies
3
Views
6K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K