My Mathematical Methods in Physics is written to weed out students, help me

AI Thread Summary
In the discussion about recommended mathematical methods in physics books, participants express dissatisfaction with the current textbook used at ASU, noting its lack of detail and clarity in explaining complex topics. Key areas of concern include the book's failure to connect mathematical concepts to physical applications, particularly in areas like differential equations, vector calculus, and Fourier analysis. Recommendations for alternative texts include "Mathematical Methods for Physicists" by Arfken & Weber, which is praised for its comprehensive coverage, and Mary Boas' book, which is also well-regarded. Some participants suggest exploring lecture notes or searching the forum for additional recommendations. The importance of developing good study habits is emphasized, especially in challenging courses.
bossman007
Messages
60
Reaction score
0
what is a mathematical methods in physics book that you all would recommend? I need One that shows enough steps, explains clearly, etc.

At ASU, my mathematical methods in phyiscs book covers the following topics with excruciatingly little detail and cryptic wording/notation, skipping so many important steps that leaves me and most everyone in the class hanging out to dry.

I want to make the mathematical connection to physics, and this book we have doesn't do that. Here's an outline of the material we cover:

1st:
Complex Arithmetic
First order diff eq's
Second order diff eq's
"Trigg" Functions - (infinite summation notation of sine and cosine)
Vector Algebra and intro to Matrices
Matrix theory
Orthogonal functions and Fourier Series
One-Dimenisonal Wave Equation

2nd half:
Vector Calculus
The delta function
Fourier Transforms
PDEs
Bessel Functions
Legendre Polynomials
Associated Legendre functions and spherical harmonics
Sturm-Liouville Theory and Orthogonal Functions
Analytic Function theory
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Which book is it?
 
[url=http://postimage.org/image/safki5jnn/][PLAIN]http://s13.postimage.org/safki5jnn/math_methods_book_cover.jpg[/url][/PLAIN]
 
Excellent, but is there a book on the market, or just some lecture notes written by the profs at your uni inspired from let's say 20,30 books ?

So you want a reccomandation for a book, then. Mine would be Arfken & Webber. You can search this forum for other useful suggestions to maybe some better books. Many people fancy the book by Mary Boas. I like A&W or even deeper, pour les connaisseurs, the 2 volumes by Morse and Feshbach.
 
Looks like lecture notes prepared by the professor specifically for this course, not a "real" textbook. I'd go with Boas or Arfken, myself, for a supplement.

Go back to the thread list for this forum, and click the "Search this forum" link at the top of the list, on the right side. Search for either "boas" or "arfken" and you'll turn up previous threads about math methods books.
 
do you read the hints at the end of the sections? usually these help enormously.

It took me a long time to get used to math methods, but rest assured, your homework in 310/314 will NOT be any easier, so work hard on this homework to get good habits developed (e.g. start the homework as soon as it is assigned).

314 is especially onerous if Schmidt teaches it.
 
Also this isn't a weedout course, the curve is extremely generous at the end.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top