Need Help with Eng Physics Problems? Get Expert Solutions in Minutes!

  • Thread starter Thread starter 9danny
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Physics
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving two engineering physics problems involving vector forces. In the first problem, the user struggles to find the angle between two equal forces whose resultant is (sqrt)2F, mistakenly calculating it as 60 degrees instead of the correct 90 degrees. In the second problem, they attempt to determine the magnitude and direction of a second force pulling on a tree stump, but their calculations yield zero, leading to confusion about the components of the forces involved. Participants suggest using vector components to clarify the relationships and apply the Pythagorean theorem correctly to find the resultant. Overall, the thread emphasizes the importance of understanding vector addition and the correct application of trigonometric functions in solving physics problems.
9danny
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
eng physics - help needed!

I have three simple problems that - even though I understand - I can't get the answer the book is saying...
1) Two forces with same magnitude F. What is the angle between the vectors if their sum has a magnitude of (sqrt)2F.

** ok - I'm doing R = (sqrt)2F therefore R = (sqrt)(Fx^2 + Fy^2) but Fx = Fy
Then R = sqrt(2F^2)
solving for F --> F= R/2 --> F= (sqrt2)/2

I'm doing (angle) = cos^-1 {[(sqrt2)/2]/[sqrt2]} but I get 60! Book is telling me it should be 90deg... **


2) Two horses pull horizontally on ropes attached to a tree stump. The two forces F1 and F2 are such that the net force R has a magnitude equal to that of F1 and makes an angle of 90 with F1. Let F1=1300N. Find the magnitude of F2 and its direction.

** The book is answering 1840N and 135 deg. I broke R into Rx and Ry, same for F1...
Rx=(1300N)cos90 = 0 Ry=(1300N)sin90=1300 etc
Then using both components for both forces F1 and R - using Rx = F1x + F2x and solving for F2x (and F2y later) and again Pitagoreas' theorem I got ::
F2 = sqrt[ F2x^2 + F2y^2 ]
which - strange - gives me zero! What did I do wrong? **
 
Physics news on Phys.org
9danny said:
1) Two forces with same magnitude F. What is the angle between the vectors if their sum has a magnitude of (sqrt)2F.

** ok - I'm doing R = (sqrt)2F therefore R = (sqrt)(Fx^2 + Fy^2) but Fx = Fy
Then R = sqrt(2F^2)
solving for F --> F= R/2 --> F= (sqrt2)/2

I'm doing (angle) = cos^-1 {[(sqrt2)/2]/[sqrt2]} but I get 60! Book is telling me it should be 90deg... **
Not sure what you are doing here. Instead, let the first vector be F in the x-direction. Let the second vector be F at some angle \theta. Now find the resultant by adding the components of the two vectors. Apply what you know about the magnitude of the resultant to solve for \theta.


2) Two horses pull horizontally on ropes attached to a tree stump. The two forces F1 and F2 are such that the net force R has a magnitude equal to that of F1 and makes an angle of 90 with F1. Let F1=1300N. Find the magnitude of F2 and its direction.

** The book is answering 1840N and 135 deg. I broke R into Rx and Ry, same for F1...
Rx=(1300N)cos90 = 0 Ry=(1300N)sin90=1300 etc
Then using both components for both forces F1 and R - using Rx = F1x + F2x and solving for F2x (and F2y later) and again Pitagoreas' theorem I got ::
F2 = sqrt[ F2x^2 + F2y^2 ]
which - strange - gives me zero! What did I do wrong?**
Nothing wrong with this method, but realize that F1y = 0.
 
The first one is definitely 90 just draw a triangle with two legs of equal side F and with a hypotenuse of Fsqrt2 you should just be able to look at that one and evaluate it. Remember put the vectors head to tail and their sum (magnitude) is the vector that goes from the tail of the first to the head of the second.
 
How can I show my work?
Fx/R = cos(angle) then solve for angle gives me 45deg
Fy/R = sin(angle) gives me 45deg -- then what? add them?
 
9danny said:
How can I show my work?
Fx/R = cos(angle) then solve for angle gives me 45deg
Fy/R = sin(angle) gives me 45deg -- then what? add them?
What problem are you referring to?
 
Doc Al said:
What problem are you referring to?


The first one.
The resultant = sqrt2 F
HELP
 
9danny said:
How can I show my work?
Fx/R = cos(angle) then solve for angle gives me 45deg
Fy/R = sin(angle) gives me 45deg -- then what? add them?
If you are referring to problem #1, R is the resultant of both vectors.

F2x = F2 cos (angle)
F2y = F2 sin (angle)

These are both true, but not especially helpful.

Instead, find the components of each vector and add them:

R_x = F + F\cos \theta
R_y = F\sin \theta

Now apply
R^2 = R_x^2 + R_y^2
 
Doc Al said:
If you are referring to problem #1, R is the resultant of both vectors.

F2x = F2 cos (angle)
F2y = F2 sin (angle)

These are both true, but not especially helpful.

Instead, find the components of each vector and add them:

R_x = F + F\cos \theta
R_y = F\sin \theta

Now apply
R^2 = R_x^2 + R_y^2


Is R_x^2 = F_x^2??
Where am I solving for the angle?
What is F?

From
R^2 = R_x^2 + R_y^2[/QUOTE]
I find that R_x = R_y... therefore R^2 = 2R'^2
Solving --> R' = (sqrt)1
Am I right?
 
I'm still not sure what you are doing. I gave you what Rx & Ry are. Plug them into the equation I gave for R^2. (Actually do the squaring!) Since you know that R^2 = 2 F^2 (that's given), plug that into the equation. Then you can solve for the angle.
 
Back
Top