Negative or positive in rolling?

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
4 replies · 2K views
uriwolln
Messages
60
Reaction score
0
When, let's say, a cylinder is rolling on a plane, and there is a rope coiled around the cylinder and the rope moves at an acceleration of A(rope) at the upper part of the cylinder to the right.
Ok, so when I try to envision it, the cylinder is rolling in the CW direction.
so R(alpha)= - A(cylinder). When the acceleration of the cylinder is relative to the ground.
but then I need to look at the spring too, right?
so since the cylinder is STILL moving in CW direction, the equation for that should be
R(alpha)= - (A(cylinder) - A(rope))
But in questions I tired to solve they took it as positive.
Am I overlooking sth?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You have a cylinder and rope and then suddenly a spring?

What's R(alpha)?

Do you have a diagram? Either I'm missing something or this is a rather confusing description.
 
For the center of mass of the cylinder a = -alpha x R. Assuming the cylinder is rolling and not slipping, the string acclerates at twice that speed. This is assuming that alpha being clockwise is a negative number, and assuming you want left to right movement to be considered as positive.
 
ok, so let me get this straight.
because the movement if from left to right, then does the equation necessarily imply
a(rope) - a (cylinder)= -r x alpha.
the negative sign again here because the cylinder rolls in CW direction.
I mean, do I always get to do, the positive acceleration - which in this case is the rope- minus the other one?