Physics problem.Only logic,no formulas.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Elaia
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Formulas Physics
AI Thread Summary
Boiling water can restart under specific conditions, particularly if atmospheric pressure changes. When cold water is poured on the outside of a dish, it may create a local low-pressure area, potentially allowing water near its boiling point to boil again. The material of the dish plays a crucial role, as it must insulate well to prevent immediate cooling of the water inside. The discussion raises questions about the reliability of such an experiment and the specific conditions under which it occurs. Overall, while it's not a general rule that cooling the outside of a container causes boiling, certain circumstances could allow it to happen.
Elaia
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
In a dish we pour water.We boil it for some moments.Then we turn off the oven and the water gets colder.The boiling is interrupted.If we pour cold water outside the dish (in contact with it) the boiling starts again.WHY does the boiling start again??
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It wouldn't. Why on Earth would it?
 
Is this the result of an actual experiment?

I could see it happening provided the water in the dish were very near boiling. Boiling temperature depends on the atmospheric pressure.

The lower the atmospheric pressure, the lower the boiling point of water. For example, water always boils at a lower temperature at high altitudes (and many recipes vary their quantities/procedure slightly for high altitude). If you were boiling water right before a storm hit, the water would also boil at a slightly lower temperature as the air pressure dropped.

If pouring the water on the outside of the dish created a local low pressure area over the dish, then water that was just barely below the boiling temperature could start boiling again. Of course, the dish would have to be made of a material that insulated very well, so that pouring cold water on the outside of the dish didn't immediately lower the temperature of the water inside the dish. In other words, if this did work, I wouldn't expect it to work for long.
 
I have to ask whether the experiment is reliably repeatable or a one-off.
 
Say the dish is metal - would the thermal contraction create a rougher surface and more nucleation sites?

Grasping at straws here.
 
Last edited:
I see you have used the word "oven". What kind of oven? Did you open a door to add water? What material was the lower dish made from? What was the oven temperature?
One of these details (or another) may give us a clue, I hope. Can you describe the whole thing nor fully?
 
It is not in general true that cooling the outside of a container will cause the water to boil.

However, under some restricted conditions this can happen, as Bob alluded. See the You Tube video.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Calling mythbusters ...
 
Back
Top