Piecewise knowledge of mathematics.

AI Thread Summary
A college freshman expresses frustration over the fragmented nature of their mathematical education, feeling unprepared for physics due to gaps in their knowledge of calculus, algebra, and trigonometry. They seek recommendations for comprehensive textbooks that cover all necessary math topics without focusing on basic problem-solving techniques. The discussion highlights the importance of a cohesive understanding of mathematics, criticizing the traditional separation of subjects in education. Suggestions include using Khan Academy for foundational math, alongside engineering and calculus textbooks to build problem-solving skills. Participants emphasize the need for a solid grasp of algebra and calculus before tackling more advanced topics like real analysis, warning against underestimating the importance of foundational concepts. The conversation underscores the necessity of continuous practice and the potential challenges of studying physics without a strong math background.
cavemen
Messages
42
Reaction score
0
Hello.

I am a college freshman.
All the sudden I understood that school taught me fragments of mathematics, not the whole thing. Different low-grade teachers that would teach us to solve a lot of simple problems fast for tests like SAT instead of learning mathematics.

I want to become a physicist.

There is a problem.
I know fragments of calculus, algebra and trigonometry. As I read into calculus textbook I understood that.

I want you to suggest me a good textbook that would cover all the necessary subjects of mathematics from Algebra to Calculus. (not useless stuff like solving quadratic equations by so-called factoring)


Also the separation onto Algebra I, ALgebra II,Trigonometry,and calculus exists only for educators, but I am certain that it CONTRIBUTED to the problem of fragmental knowledge of mathematics. I come to a new level and I am tought stuff but when we reach the end, we run out of time. Then I go to a higher level of mathematics an I am missing some basic knowledge. And so on it went,'till I got all my credits and realized that high school is a big waste of time.



Since I am not the greatest mathematitian I would like to have a textbook where everything is written in a form of 'identity' or " this equates to this " form.

This is the way I noticed that I learn well.

I simply don't know where to begin with.
If you are an educator, please take note of what I am saying as this may be a problem with some of your students.

Thank you.
Have a great day.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
www.khanacademy.org

If you study all of the mathematics up through calculus on this site, and supplement yourself with an engineering book like this https://www.amazon.com/dp/0750685557/?tag=pfamazon01-20 to practice doing questions & problem solving etc... then in about a month or so (hopefully quicker!) you'll be able to start studying a good physics book like University Physics https://www.amazon.com/dp/080538684X/?tag=pfamazon01-20 , this physics book is simply the best and clearest intro there is (IMO).

I really mean it when I say do ALL of the math on that site, khanacademy, & definitely get at least the engineering book because it covers all of the basic math & calculus needed for University Physics. Furthermore, I advise getting Schaums 3000 solved problems after you finish a good few chapters of University Physics to have another source for testing yourself. Btw, to have khanacademy.org available to you is very lucky for you, the guy will explain things so well that you'll feel confident enough in your math after going through ALL of the videos, but get another book to test yourself!

When you're up to at least the calculus stuff on both Khanacademy & in the engineering book I really advise you to get a good calculus book too, at least Stewart Calculus or Thomas Calculus.

Then if you finish all this stuff you'll be able to move on to other stuff, but it takes time & continual failure/re-starts lol
 
Last edited by a moderator:
cavemen said:
(not useless stuff like solving quadratic equations by so-called factoring)
Can you then tell me what is useful maths?
 
http://www.maths.mq.edu.au/~wchen/ln.html"

Too me, it sounds like you crave a book in real analysis. I gone through the same thing after I completed Calculus. Try
Real Analysis-Haasar, Sullivan or
Introductory Real Analysis-Kolmogorov or
Principals of Mathematical Analysis-Rudin
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thank you.
I think i found something, but let me look up the name of the author.

------------------------------
there are a lot of useless parts of math that they teach in school to fill up the cariculum
especially algebraII course.
 
If you want an excellent textbook I would highly recommend https://www.amazon.com/dp/0471198269/?tag=pfamazon01-20

Preferably purchase it as it will have all the basic and advance maths you need to know to become a physicist. Alternatively, hire it from your nearest university library.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The guy saids he knows fragments of trigonometry & calculus, how can you expect him to cope with real analysis? Or Mary Boas book? I mean, you can't get into any of the substance of Boas' book without the calculus, end of! (unfortunately know this from experience).

I bet you'll waste a load of time before you come back and clear up your trigonometry skills, let alone calculus skills. It is a guarantee that you'll only have to stop your studies of physics to go back over the essentials, again and again if you don't do it properly.


EDIT: You must be joking claiming algebra II is a waste of time.

Good luck with that arrogance, I didn't know I wasted my time with "filler" material like logs, exponents, factoring quadratics & cubics, it's not like these things ever come up when doing physics, they are not on nearly every page or anything...

I hope you update us on your progress through physics & calculus seeing as you don't appreciate/know how to factor a quadratic. I mean, yahoo answers can only give the right answers so many times...


http://tutorial.math.lamar.edu/Classes/Alg/Alg.aspx

That is a self consistent pdf of all of the basic algebra you'll need to actually do some physics, if you a) don't know all this stuff cold, & b) get some supplementary material so that you can do practice problems, I won't feel sorry for you when you get so frustrated that you feel like quitting the study of physics due to math related injuries...
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

Replies
20
Views
3K
Replies
13
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
4K
Replies
13
Views
5K
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
34
Views
6K
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top