Probability Riddle

  • Thread starter micromass
  • Start date
  • #1
22,089
3,286
I have two children. One is a boy born on a Tuesday. What is the probability I have two boys?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Matterwave
Science Advisor
Gold Member
3,965
326
50%

chars
 
  • #3
AlephZero
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
6,994
291
50%
Start with an apparently simpler problem:

"I have two children. One is a boy. What is the probability I have two boys?"

It might be more obvious that 50% is the wrong answer to that one.
 
  • #4
Matterwave
Science Advisor
Gold Member
3,965
326
Well if you didn't tell me that one is a boy. I would say the chances are 1/4 since there are BB BG GB GG. But given that you have told me one is a boy...I'm either thinking 1/2 still or 1/3.
 
  • #5
cjl
Science Advisor
1,864
437
I'm going to go with 1/3 for this one. If the question were "I have two children. The first is a boy. What is the probability that I have two boys?", then the answer would be 50%.
 
  • #6
22,089
3,286
None of the numbers in this thread are answers to the original question yet.
 
  • #7
Nathanael
Homework Helper
1,650
239
Is it perhaps 6/14? (I'm only guessing this based on the fact that the 1/2 is wrong, but I still feel it should be 1/2 :tongue:)

I won't explain myself unless I am confirmed correct (for the sake of not giving out too many hints).
 
  • #8
22,089
3,286
Is it perhaps 6/14? (I'm only guessing this based on the fact that the 1/2 is wrong, but I still feel it should be 1/2 :tongue:)

I won't explain myself unless I am confirmed correct (for the sake of not giving out too many hints).
Incorrect.
 
  • #9
259
786
In order to be another boy it NEEDS to be born on another Tuesday. There are 7 days a week and you can only have another every 9 months. Once the ninth month is hit there are only 21 days available for the child to be born. Not more, not less. In those 21 there are only 3 Tuesdays, which means:

3/21 = 1/7 = 14.something%

But all the other days are girls, which means there's somewhat 85% chance it will be a girl. Therefore, you had roughly 14% chances of having another boy.
 
  • #10
drizzle
Gold Member
366
57
  • #11
Matterwave
Science Advisor
Gold Member
3,965
326
None of the numbers in this thread are answers to the original question yet.
Is the answer slightly under 1/3 because of the probability of a hermaphrodite child?
 
  • #12
22,089
3,286
In order to be another boy it NEEDS to be born on another Tuesday. There are 7 days a week and you can only have another every 9 months. Once the ninth month is hit there are only 21 days available for the child to be born. Not more, not less. In those 21 there are only 3 Tuesdays, which means:

3/21 = 1/7 = 14.something%

But all the other days are girls, which means there's somewhat 85% chance it will be a girl. Therefore, you had roughly 14% chances of having another boy.
No.

Do I need to know this?
Yes.

Is the answer slightly under 1/3 because of the probability of a hermaphrodite child?
No. To clarify, here are the rules:

1) we’re ruling out twins,
2) we’re pretending that boys and girls are born with equal likelihood, and
3) we’re assuming that there is no correlation between a child’s sex and the day of the week on which they’re born.
 
  • #13
Matterwave
Science Advisor
Gold Member
3,965
326
Well, I guess we can list out all possibilities. The first column being the gender and the second column being the day:

BMBM BMBT BMBW BMBTH BMBF BMBS BMBSU
BTBM BTBT BTBW BTBTH BTBF BTBS BTBSU ...

BMGM BMGT BMGW BMGTH BMGF BMGS BMBSU...

GMBM GMBT GMBW GMBTH GMBF GMBS GMBSU...

GMGM GMGT GMGW GMGTH GMGF GMGS GMGSU...

Each block has 49 entries. The GG block is eliminated.

In the first block there are 13 entries with at least 1 boy born on Tuesday. In the second block there are 7 entries with a boy born on Tuesday, and in the third block there are 7 entries with a boy born on Tuesday. That's 27 total entries with a boy born at least on Tuesday. Of those 27 entries 13 are both boys while the other 14 have girls in them. So the probability is 13/27.
 
  • #14
22,089
3,286
Well, I guess we can list out all possibilities. The first column being the gender and the second column being the day:

BMBM BMBT BMBW BMBTH BMBF BMBS BMBSU
BTBM BTBT BTBW BTBTH BTBF BTBS BTBSU ...

BMGM BMGT BMGW BMGTH BMGF BMGS BMBSU...

GMBM GMBT GMBW GMBTH GMBF GMBS GMBSU...

GMGM GMGT GMGW GMGTH GMGF GMGS GMGSU...

Each block has 49 entries. The GG block is eliminated.

In the first block there are 13 entries with at least 1 boy born on Tuesday. In the second block there are 7 entries with a boy born on Tuesday, and in the third block there are 7 entries with a boy born on Tuesday. That's 27 total entries with a boy born at least on Tuesday. Of those 27 entries 13 are both boys while the other 14 have girls in them. So the probability is 13/27.
Congratulations.

http://johncarlosbaez.wordpress.com/2010/08/24/probability-puzzles-from-egan/
http://gregegan.customer.netspace.net.au/ESSAYS/TUESDAY/Tuesday.html
 
  • #15
662
307
Do I need to know this?
Yes.
1st child Tuesday boy, 2nd girl on random day=7
1st child Tuesday boy, 2nd boy on random day=7
2nd child Tuesday boy, 1st girl on random day=7
2nd child Tuesday boy, 1st boy on random day=7

total=28-1=27

P=13/27
EDIT: nvm, too slow...
 
  • #16
lisab
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
1,887
616
Not enough information.

You never said you have exactly two children.
 
  • #17
AlephZero
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
6,994
291
Do I need to know this?
Well, you don't need to know it was Tuesday. The probability would be the same for any named day of the week.

Of course that logic suggests another way to get the wrong answer: find the probability of some other situation, and divide it by 7 :devil:
 
  • #18
PeroK
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
14,711
6,955
I have two children. One is a boy born on a Tuesday. What is the probability I have two boys?
Here's how I'd look at it:

Given you have exactly two children, imagine asking each family with exactly two children the same question. Do you have a boy born on a Tuesday?

Typical families are: GG (25%), GB (50%), BB (25%).

The families with two girls always answer no, and the families with two boys are more likely to answer yes (with two boys, it's more likely one was born on a Tuesday). How much more likely depends on the rarity of the required property (for a rare property, it would be almost double; for a common property it may make very little difference).

In this case, it's almost double (roughly) so, the GB and BB cases are almost equally likely.

However, if you have simply volunteered this information without my asking, I'm not so sure:

You go to every family and they are asked to say whether they have a boy and, if so, volunteer a day of the week on which the boy was born, then you might not reach the same conclusion for every family with at least one boy:

The first family might say: we have a boy born on Monday. The second family might say: we have a boy born on Thursday. The third family might say: we have no boys. The fourth family might say: we have a boy born on Tuesday.

In this case, the probability of 2 boys is 1/3 as the additional information in each case implies nothing.
 
Last edited:
  • #19
Vanadium 50
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
2019 Award
25,380
8,557
PeroK starts in the right place.

There are three possibilities per child, which I will label as G, for a girl, T for a boy born on Tuesday, and N for a boy not born on a Tuesday. Ordering the children, here are the outcomes and their probabilities:

GG = 1/4 = 49/196
GN = 3/14 = 42/196
NG = 3/14 = 42/196
GT = 1/28 = 7/196 *
TG = 1/28 = 7/196 *
NN = 9/49 = 36/196
NT = 3/98 = 6/196 *
TN = 3/98 = 6/196 *
TT = 1/196 = 1/196 *

We are told one child is a boy born on Tuesday. That means we are in one of the 5 asterisked outcomes.
Of them, the outcomes with two boys are NT, TN and TT, for a probability of 13/27.
 
  • #20
PeroK
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
14,711
6,955
I believe it makes a big difference if the information is volunteered. All families with at least one boy can quote a day of the week on which a son was born. This volunteered information does not exclude any family nor make it more likely they have two boys.
On the other hand if the family is asked whether they have a boy born on Tuesday, this does exclude many families and excludes more who have only one boy.

These are two different situations.

By volunteering this information the problem does not work as intended. The day of the week must be chosen by an external questioner and not chosen by the family.

Every family with at least one boy could do what Micomass did and say: We have a boy born on xxxday.
 
  • #21
Borek
Mentor
28,530
2,963
Perhaps my English fails me, but the answer to the question whether "one is a boy born on a Tuesday" means "if the other is a boy, he wasn't born on a Tuesday" is not obvious.
 
  • #22
PeroK
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
14,711
6,955
PeroK starts in the right place.

There are three possibilities per child, which I will label as G, for a girl, T for a boy born on Tuesday, and N for a boy not born on a Tuesday. Ordering the children, here are the outcomes and their probabilities:

GG = 1/4 = 49/196
GN = 3/14 = 42/196
NG = 3/14 = 42/196
GT = 1/28 = 7/196 *
TG = 1/28 = 7/196 *
NN = 9/49 = 36/196
NT = 3/98 = 6/196 *
TN = 3/98 = 6/196 *
TT = 1/196 = 1/196 *

We are told one child is a boy born on Tuesday. That means we are in one of the 5 asterisked outcomes.
Of them, the outcomes with two boys are NT, TN and TT, for a probability of 13/27.
I've spotted the flaw in this. The family with 1 boy born on Tuesday will always say "Tuesday". But the family with 2 boys only one of which is born on a Tuesday will not always say"Tuesday". So these options listed with asterisks are not equally likely.

If you talk to each family in turn then approx half the families with 2 boys will not say tuesday but the day of the week on which the other boy was born.

That's why you have to ask the question. Then all relevant families will say yes every time. It doesn't work if they volunteer the information.
 
  • #23
PeroK
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
14,711
6,955
I have two children. One is a boy born on a Tuesday. What is the probability I have two boys?
I was thinking about this again and I realised that there is another flaw in the expected solution. The difficulty is to know what one can infer from this statement. There's no problem with the statement about having two children implying that its a typical family with the usual equal probabilities of:

BB, BG, GB, GG

But, what can one infer from the simple statement that "one is a boy"? Let's assume this means "at least one is a boy".

One could argue that of the four families, the BB would say this, one of the BG/GB would also say "one is a boy", but the other BG/GB would say "one is a girl", and the GG would obviously say "one is a girl".

So, of the 4 typical families, two would say "one is a boy", one of these would have two boys and one would have a boy and a girl. This would mean that:

If someone says "I have two children and at least one is a boy", then the probability the other is a boy is, actually, 50%! Assuming this information was freely volunteered with no preconditions.

(It's different of course if the person is asked "do you have at least one boy"? Then the probability of having two boys is 1/3, as we all know.)

The added information about the day of the week doesn't change anything, since the information is freely volunteered and it has to be one day of the week.

So, the correct answer to the original problem is 1/2.

To be precise, this is how I have interpreted the original problem:

Micromass has two children. He picked one at random and told us the sex and the day of the week it was born.

This, if you think about it, implies nothing about the other child.
 
  • Like
Likes Ygggdrasil
  • #24
1,184
223
Perhaps my English fails me, but the answer to the question whether "one is a boy born on a Tuesday" means "if the other is a boy, he wasn't born on a Tuesday" is not obvious.
Yeah. Therefore, 50% :)
 
  • #25
130
13
The result 13/27 is counter intuitive because we somehow assume that the information provided about one child won't effect the other. This assumption is valid only when we know whether the info applies to the older or younger child while in this problem the child can be either younger or older.
 

Related Threads on Probability Riddle

  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
23
Views
10K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
869
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
14
Views
6K
  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
19
Views
8K
  • Last Post
3
Replies
50
Views
43K
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
736
Top